Biggest Loser 11/10 - Spoilers!

You're freaking annoying.... but way to go, Shay.

Wow!!!! That is freakin awesome!!!!!

This is the craziest week yet!!!  How in the world are they dropping such HUGE numbers!?!?!  Is that really healthy?

I am excited for all of them because they are doing amazing, but man...this week sucks...Immunity and two people going home?  Its heart breaking all around for some of them!!!

Since when did Li z JUST START playing the game.  She has done nothing but since the start.  Always angry about something.  Ready to see HER go home.

They didn't show a before and after picture of Shay because......

Brian

I keep hearing this. Why exactly is it unhealthy to lose more than the 2 lbs per week. I hear it a lot, but it's always been like, drink lots of water. Repeated often, but I don't ever hear the why.

Jillian is mental - why does she think she should work harder with Shay than others - isn't Jillian playing the game then.

WTF - what was Jillian doing with the stupid workout with Rudy doing handcrawls on the treadmill. Jillian is an idiot who seriously is going to hurt someone one day.


BYE BYE SHAY - to much b'ing & m'ing for me.

I echo the above post...WHY did they not show a before and after of Shay??

I wondered that as well.

While I was sick of Shay crying... she needed to stay there more than Amanda.

The trapeze work was a little lame... I mean they never really DID anything! They just ran and back and forth with it.

Shay was on Leno. She looked good. Lost 150lbs to date.

OK, did anyone else notice the crappy food at Shay's house for her welcome home party? There was a huge box of cupcakes and several bags of chips off to the side. It was quick but there was a ton of junk food in that room. I think she will have a hard time staying on track at home, but I hope she can.

Edited by bayrunner 2009-11-11 6:38 AM

I glad she's still losing, though I'm also glad she's off the show.  She annoyed me from day 1!  The only one left that still annoys me is Liz, though she's really not so bad now that Tracey is gone.

Brian

Yeah Shay annoyed me too. But what a bummer, losing 17lbs and still being under the yellow line. Brutal.

Just amazed at how far Dan has come - in 9 months more than 200lbs. it's amazing! Sad to see his friend from last season though.

To be honest, Shay didn't bug me as much as Daniel actually did. I kind of felt he wasn't really pushing himself that hard throughout, and was coasting a little--and piggy backing on the "Shay needs to stay here" excuse when they were a team.

It was pretty heartbreaking to see him sitting down with his friend from last season, though, and hearing him say he didn't "feel unhealthy"...

Oooh, also, also, forgot this part--who is Dan's girlfriend that he's going to introduce everyone to at the finale? Think it's one of the contestants??

Shay needs more help than can be provided by Jillian's pseudo-psychoanalytical sessions.  I hope the best for the her, but have my doubts for her long term.  She is still huge after losing 100lbs.  While she "needed" to be there more, for pure entertainment, she was the most annoying person left, and there will be fewer cringe/snarl inducing comments now.  I would suggest that maybe they bring her back next season like Daniel, except, Daniel was somewhat endearing and was hosed by his partner.  Shay was neither.

The next 2 most annoying are Liz and Amanda.  Liz is always griping.  Amanda has yet to miss a opportunity to say "America chose me."  Amanda, it was just you and one other.  The odds were 50/50.  Get over it.

I thought it was ironic that the younger four were doing extra workouts at night, but 3 of them ended up below the yellow line!

Brian

Dan and Liz must be having a secret affair?

Bob and Amanda were more discreet about their affair this week

Brian

Oh, I never thought of that. Maybe it's...Bob.

Teehee.

I think deep down Jillian  knew Shay was going home, Jillian knew she needed to push her past whatever was holding her back, shay needed to be shown what it was going to take to be able to continue on her own. If anyone has gotten a pass it has been Daniel, 2 seasons now!
It was sad to see them all sneak extra workouts during sleeping hours adding minimal results, I do believe they hurt themselves by reducing thier recovery, when doing high intensity work, rest is just as important.
I think because of Bob and Jillians pupularity, they are exposed to all kinds of new workouts and techniques, looks like Jillian was experimenting with Rudy, dont think that technique will be used again. I do believe there is a ton of trial and error stuff on that show.
I dont think its unhealthy what they are doing, I think most of them are not  healthy to begin with, I think when you see huge weight loss is a combination of strict diet,adding muscle, burning fat. 

My wife & I said it was a bad idea even before the weigh-in.

You body needs rest & recovery and you can stress it to a point that you will stop losing.

No matter what the BS - calories in calories burned is all that matters to lose weight that this show preaches - time & time again it is proven incorrect.

Factors such as mental stress, exhaustion, plateauing and other factors weigh in. (No pun intended)

Also - Shay complained that Rudy would have been on the line without immunity, well you know he watered-up and still lost 8 pounds. She is clueless.