General Discussion Triathlon Talk » tri bike or road bike Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
tri bike or road bike
OptionResults
tri bike13 Votes - [41.94%]
road bike18 Votes - [58.06%]

2006-07-21 10:22 AM

User image

Veteran
179
100252525
Subject: tri bike or road bike
just wondering what other athletes have to say about the two options of tri bike or road bike. i am thinking of getting a new bike and have gotten some great advice on purchasing one (thanks bear) but i still dont know what kind to get. i have read numerous reviews on the topic but i still dont know for sure. please help with this problem. please leave a comment on why you voted the way you did.


2006-07-21 10:31 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Not a Coach
11473
5000500010001001001001002525
Media, PA
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
BLACK

Edited by JohnnyKay 2006-07-21 10:31 AM
2006-07-21 10:32 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Pro
3906
20001000500100100100100
Libertyville, IL
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

As a beginner to true cycling, I was convinced that I would not be skilled enough with the aeros, clipless, etc, etc and also thought I might ride some fun rides with brewery tours tacked on em, so I went with a Cervelo One road bike and had them fit me with an aero set up.  I still love her lots and we have grown a lot together.  That said, I hope to soon get a true tri bike as the distances grow BUT I will be doing a lot of test riding to convince me that there is a true benefit to me.  So to sum it up, I went road due to:

1.  Limited riding ability

2.  In case I did more 'social' type touring rides

3.  Lack of balls to go full aero off the bat

All in all, I keep getting faster on er and I was able to run a 19:30 5k off of her in my sprint in early June, which aint too shabby off the pace of my regular top end 5k's.

2006-07-21 10:39 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Master
2299
2000100100252525
New York
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I didn't actually realize this was a "what do you think" poll till after I voted. I have a tri-bike now, but was originally on a Felt road bike w/clip ons. I think it is totally dependent on the person making the purchasing decision. Personally, I am much faster and more comfortable on my Dual.
2006-07-21 10:46 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Champion
7036
5000200025
Sarasota, FL
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

I was intending to buy a tri bike last year, but the guys at my LBS persuaded me to buy a road bike instead.  They told me that I didn't need a tri bike until I was "doing more than seven triathlons per year".  (no, I don't have a clue where they came up with that).

Well I bought a road bike, a Cannondale R700, and really do like it.  But at the same time 99% percent of my riding has been either training for, or racing in, triathlons.   A tri bike would have worked just fine too.   

I've considered buying a new tri bike, but at this point my road bike isn't my limiting factor - I am.  My Cannondale is still faster than I can ride it.  Once I start wearing out my 11T sprocket all the time then maybe I'll start shopping for a new ride.

Mark    

2006-07-21 10:47 AM
in reply to: #489277

Veteran
204
100100
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I voted tri bike, you can ride these in group rides and if you are serious about tri's then why buy 2 bikes which you would eventually do. I am saving for my tri bike now but I have been riding road for over 10 years on the same old Schwinn Super Sport.


2006-07-21 10:58 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Expert
919
500100100100100
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I have both bikes and my road bike gets no attention. I made the decision that tri's are strickly what I wanted to do and train for. My road bike is rather hard on my body compared to my tri bike which I can ride for hours. But, (there is always a but) as others noted you can't go wrong with a road bike either.

Also, my tribike is RED.
2006-07-21 11:33 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Extreme Veteran
345
10010010025
Tucson, AZ
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I'd say get what fits you in stature and wallet.  I went with the road bike bc it was about $1K cheaper than a full out tri bike with the same gear.  Now I went ahead and got the clipless b/c I already had them on my MTB and I got the aero's to get used to them as fast as possible, even if I don't use them much right away.
2006-07-21 11:41 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Resident Curmudgeon
25290
50005000500050005000100100252525
The Road Back
Gold member
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

BOTH!

Really, depends on what your riding style and goals dictate. I have both, do about 75-80% of my mileage on my road bike, also have it to do group rides and centuries, which I was doing more of when I got it. That's another reason to wait a year before plunking down the coin, to get a better idea of what kind of cycling you want to do.

But, really, if someone is certain that all the cycling the're going to do is triathlon/time-trial related, I have no problem with them going directly to the tri bike.

2006-07-21 11:44 AM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Extreme Veteran
596
500252525
Worcester, MA
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
What about if you live in a very hilly area? there is no where I can ride around here without some significant hills. Does it make a difference?
2006-07-21 12:23 PM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Extreme Veteran
405
100100100100
East Aurora, NY
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

I voted road bike, but this is my opinion and is based on my limited experience thus far.  I am green to the sport of cycling (unless you count all of the biking I did in my youth before I earned a drivers license) and have been debating over the past several months...road or tri...road or tri.  I have decided that I would like a road bike because of the following reasons:

  1. Would like the option of getting in on group rides.
  2. Want to learn how to handle a bike very well before moving onto a tri bike.
  3. I don't plan on any long distance (i.e HIM or IM) races anytime soon. 
  4. Plan on doing several sprint tris a season (4-5 races).

I feel that, for me anyway, the road bike will be the way to go.  I can get experience with how a real racing built bike handles and I can build my engine.  I have ambitions to someday complete a HIM and then a IM distance race.  When I reach that point I expect that I will want a tri specific bike. 

Just my .02. 

 



2006-07-21 1:05 PM
in reply to: #489277

Master
1315
1000100100100
Shreveport, LA
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
If I remember correctly, you are on a pretty tight budget. I doubt that you can find many used tri bikes for less than $500 or $600, but I could be wrong.

You should be able to find a good road bike that fits for less than that though.

I think the Bear gave me the best advice when I was trying to decide whether or not to keep the road bike and tri bike or sell both and buy a nicer road bike. He told me that each inspired the other. In other words, when he put in the miles on his road bike and then added an extra 2-3 mph when he jumped on the tri bike, he could work harder on the road bike because he knew that he would be rewarded on the tri bike.

For me, I decided to go with one bike for now and that is the road bike, but I am selling my tri bike and my road bike and buying a nice road bike.

I am test riding a Cervelo Soloist next week, because it supposedly does a good job of being both a road bike and a sometimes tri bike, because I want to do the local road races around here and I can't do that on tri bike.

Anyway, buy something that fits and you will love to ride.
2006-07-21 1:21 PM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Champion
6786
50001000500100100252525
Two seat rocket plane
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

I agree with Bear

Both

But get the road bike first

The correct number of bikes to own is N+1 where N = (the number of bikes you have now)

you're welcome

2006-07-21 2:14 PM
in reply to: #489559

User image

Science Nerd
28760
50005000500050005000200010005001001002525
Redwood City, California
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
ride_like_u_stole_it - 2006-07-21 2:21 PM

I agree with Bear

Both

But get the road bike first

The correct number of bikes to own is N+1 where N = (the number of bikes you have now)

you're welcome

Can you send that to my husband.  He just doesn't understand. 

Related to the thread, I got a road bike instead of a tri bike. I'm very happy with my road bike, but I'll look into getting a tri bike in the next year or two because I want to do longer races (right now, I'm only doing sprints and olys.

2006-07-21 3:07 PM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Extreme Veteran
438
10010010010025
Surprise, AZ
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
My thoughts:

I purchased a entry level road bike GIANT OCR1 on closeout and put clipon areo bars. Road that for a while to get an idea of what to look for in a tribike, then bought a Cannondale Ironaman 2000 on closeout some time later. Love the tribike and use the road bike only for indoor use. Really glad I have both and in that order.
2006-07-21 4:40 PM
in reply to: #489277

User image

Master
1404
1000100100100100
Atlanta, Ga
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I bought a tri bike first, and will by a tri bike second. They both do the same thing, just differently.  I am not a cyclist and could care less what rodies think if I ever do a century or anything of that sort. I am a triathlete, therefore, a tri bike made the most sense. I have not looked back since.
If I ever find myself flush with cash, perhaps I will buy a road bike, or maybe a ITU bike like the Felt T-23 which is as close to both as you will find. Either way, I will always be partial to my tri bike.


2006-07-21 4:42 PM
in reply to: #489277

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
2006-07-21 7:18 PM
in reply to: #489277

SF Bay Area, Mountain View
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
funny coincidece that you should ask right now.

a Specialized shop opened 2 weeks ago in my neighborhood and i went by today for them to take care of a recall on my 2005 Allez Elite. that is NOT a Tri bike. while given the chance i rode a $5000 2006 Transition. it feels like being in the start position for a 100 yd dash and staying that way.

i think tri bikes are hyped. if you are in WAY good shape, know the course and aiming for placing, then consider one. if you are just riding along for the fun, get a road bike and and clip ons.

other than that - don't get a tri bike.


edit: especially if there's hills.

Edited by awol 2006-07-21 7:20 PM
2006-07-21 7:33 PM
in reply to: #489277

Veteran
225
10010025
Dothan, Alabama
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
Road bike first, tune and train the engine well. Then, if/when going longer add the tri-bike. That's my plan and it's worked well so far. I'm fighting temptation to jump on a tri-bike now, but I console myself that the longer I wait, the nicer the bike will be when I pull the trigger.
2006-07-21 7:41 PM
in reply to: #489277

Extreme Veteran
493
100100100100252525
Bay Area, CA
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

I have my road bike (a beloved Pinarello purchased in Italy) and my MTB (a VooDoo, anyone remember VooDoo?). I started out as a cyclist and only got into tri-ing when I realized I'd done all three sports at various points in my life successfully. I think I will get a tri bike if I graduate to long course--say, post 1 HIM. I don't want to test drive one now, though, because I don't want to fall out of love with my Italian steed.

Anywho...Roadies ride those things for centuries, dual centuries, blah, blah, so yeah--just figure out what kind of riding you think you want to do.

2006-07-21 9:08 PM
in reply to: #489277

Member
37
25
Lakewood, Colorado
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I asked the same question not two weeks ago. I still have not bought my new bike, but all my training will be for triathlons. There was an article about how it is easier to run after riding the Tri-bike that "the Bear" posted on the thread. All my riding will be in Colorado. All my triathlons will be in Colorado. All my training will be in Colorado. Knowing that we "play like we practice", and after reading the link "The Bear" posted... my new bike will be a tri-bike.


2006-07-21 9:11 PM
in reply to: #489277

Champion
19812
50005000500020002000500100100100
MA
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike

I have a road bike and just bought a tri bike and that's all I ride. I ride my 98% of the time by myself so the group ride/handling thing isn't really an issue. My coach encouraged me to get a tri bike instead of a road bike since it fit me well and that is my main goal. My bike fits great and it is a joy to ride.

But one can never have enough bikes, right?

2006-07-22 1:40 PM
in reply to: #489277

Champion
10154
500050001002525
Alabama
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I had the same dilema back in January and I bought a tri bike....I should have bought a road bike and I'll tell you why.

1. I am not a strong enough biker to not have the 3rd ring up front. I have a few hills where I train and it's all I can do to climb them w/o the 'grandma' gear.

2. My tri bike came with a 10-23 cassette on the back and I had to change it to a 10-27 to give me more climbing power - this was cheaper than adding a 3rd ring up front.

3. I did not like the shifters on the aerobars. I spend most of my time on the horns and didn't like not having my shifters at my fingertips. So I changed from aero shifters to STI shifters on the horns

I'm ride for fun and exercise and do triathlons for the same and a tri-bike is a little too 'aggressive' for me.

Having said that, I love my bike! OK, so I've almost converted it to a road bike save for the frame angle. :-)

~Mike
2006-07-22 1:57 PM
in reply to: #489277

Elite
3067
200010002525
Cheesehead, WI
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
I used to have a road bike and mountain bike. Rode the mtb wayyy more...more comfy and less likely to have hassles with flats. Then sold them both and got a hybred. Which has used for countless family rides, vacations, etc... Then bought a road bike while in Vegas. I love how it feels and goes (faster than the hybred). But I don't use it with family rides nor vaca rides (which is with the family).
I used the road bike for my first tri and felt fine on it but did see a few tri bikes zoom by -- one with a no-spoke type wheel sounded like a freight train. Anyhow, I guess if I were to take up triathlon events more regularly, I'd look to add to the collection but I think I'd get some heat from my husband to either not spend a fortune or get rid of the road bike. At this point, I highly doubt a tri bike would speed my finish but if I were to go on to longer tri's - I think the aerobars would be a lot more comfy!
2006-07-22 2:23 PM
in reply to: #489277

Extreme Veteran
321
100100100
Guelph
Subject: RE: tri bike or road bike
Im a newbie to the sport so take my comments for what they are worth. I have an old Steve Bauer road bike that I picked up for next to nothing. Nice frame configuration, 700x25 tires and all I did to it was add aero bars. In my last race I passed alot of 1500-3000 bikes, and finished in the top 30 out of 280. Don't get me wrong I would love to have a tricked out expensive ride and I would probably pick a tri-bike. However I have committed to train and develope myself until I feel my bike is holding me back (not yet). At a weekend sport level I think you would do well in either bike so it depends on how high you want to go and if tri are the only thing you will use it for.
Oh yeah also depends how deep your pockets are!!
my 2c

Edited by Tring at 44 2006-07-22 2:29 PM
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » tri bike or road bike Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2