Other Resources The Political Joe » Ukraine Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 3
 
 
2014-02-24 10:55 AM

User image

Pro
9391
500020002000100100100252525
Omaha, NE
Subject: Ukraine

How Ukraine lost control over its own destiny

I have been following what's going on in Ukraine without a lot of knowledge on the history.  I just read this opinion piece and found it fascinating.

From afar, it seems optimistic and exciting when countries fight for democracy and want to push out corruption.  However, this opinion piece tells a tale of just how difficult it would be for the democratic movement to truly succeed.

The quote that really stood out to me:  "If you don’t control your finances and energy, you don’t control your destiny. "

 



2014-02-25 2:33 PM
in reply to: tuwood

User image

Champion
16151
50005000500010001002525
Checkin' out the podium girls
Subject: RE: Ukraine
Ukraine is a very polar country; worse that republicans and democrats. Eastern area and very pro Russian and long for the days of Soviet rule. Western Ukraine is very pro Western longing to become their own identity. The languages are even held sacrosanct as Russian and Ukrainian are spoken in the selective regions.

I don't see an easy answer other than splitting in 2. Much like Iraq and their strongly rooted factions who are forced to live as one.
2014-03-03 8:40 PM
in reply to: pitt83

User image

Master
2802
2000500100100100
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: Ukraine
Agree. It never seems to work when disparate ethnicities/groups/whatever are forced to "make a country".

So much for your $50 billion of goodwill Mr. Putin. I don't think anyone outside of Russia or the immediate area is going to be booking a trip to Sochi anytime soon.
2014-03-03 8:51 PM
in reply to: 0

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

I don't know.  Russia's entire Black Sea fleet is based on the Crimean peninsula.....if the Ukraine is going to dissolve into unrest, they are probably making the only move they can. 

No, it's not lost on me that Russia/Putin steered Kiev away from the promise of more pro-western govt. that Yanukovych was elected on, and Ukrainians were right to oust him.....but here they are, now dealing with Putin on a different level.

Russia will protect it's interests in the region.  Putin has no fear of the West.  My bet is that Crimea, at a minimum, becomes part of Russia no matter how much Obama and the rest of the Western leaders jump up and down.



Edited by Left Brain 2014-03-03 8:56 PM
2014-03-03 8:58 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Master
2802
2000500100100100
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: Ukraine
Agree, that we don't hold many good cards, but I would have to think that Putin is going to be getting a lot of pressure from the Russian Mafia/Billionaires/Moneyed that he needs in his camp to resolve this peacefully and just extract a long-term agreement from the make-shift Ukraine government to keep troops there. Ruble hit the lowest point in 5 years (I believe I heard that) and world markets are reeling a bit and an embargo on Russian oil/natural gas could be painful.... He doesn't care a rats a$$ for the actual people in the Crimea.
2014-03-03 9:04 PM
in reply to: 0

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by ejshowers Agree, that we don't hold many good cards, but I would have to think that Putin is going to be getting a lot of pressure from the Russian Mafia/Billionaires/Moneyed that he needs in his camp to resolve this peacefully and just extract a long-term agreement from the make-shift Ukraine government to keep troops there. Ruble hit the lowest point in 5 years (I believe I heard that) and world markets are reeling a bit and an embargo on Russian oil/natural gas could be painful.... He doesn't care a rats a$$ for the actual people in the Crimea.

It depends......if Putin stops at the occupation/annexation of Crimea, things may settle down and the world will be happy to go on.  The ball is actually in the hands of the Ukranian people.....how much fight do they have?  They elected a weak leader who was compromised by Putin......he's still KGB at his core and longs for the days of the Soviet Union, no?   The Ukranians and the world may be better served to cut their losses and move on.

Now......if Putin moves on Kiev, then yeah, he's going to have much bigger probelms.  I just think the folks who think Putin hasn't thought this out are underestimating the guy.



Edited by Left Brain 2014-03-03 9:06 PM


2014-03-03 9:11 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Master
2802
2000500100100100
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: Ukraine
Good point and I agree - a lot depends on how the western Ukrainians react. If they go all out and are getting slaughtered, things could get ugly as I dont see the West taking that very well. Let's all hope for just a few weeks of saber rattling before things calm down, however it plays out on the Geo-Political chess board.
2014-03-03 9:18 PM
in reply to: ejshowers

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by ejshowers Good point and I agree - a lot depends on how the western Ukrainians react. If they go all out and are getting slaughtered, things could get ugly as I dont see the West taking that very well. Let's all hope for just a few weeks of saber rattling before things calm down, however it plays out on the Geo-Political chess board.

Agree completely. 

My great-grandparents emigrated here from the former Yugoslavia.....I have always been keenly interested in the history and politics of the region.  It's pretty fascinating really.  The different cultures who live together in a very small area of the world makes it a much more volatile place then our country could ever be, no matter our differences. 

It's funny to me how different we see each other here......we're actually much more civil toward differences than much of the world is, and our differences certainly don't add up to much worth fighting for.

2014-03-04 7:42 AM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Champion
6993
50001000500100100100100252525
Chicago, Illinois
Subject: RE: Ukraine
My girlfriend from Bosnia who left during the war sees similar parallels between what is happening in Ukraine and what happened in Bosnia.
2014-03-04 9:00 AM
in reply to: chirunner134

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by chirunner134 My girlfriend from Bosnia who left during the war sees similar parallels between what is happening in Ukraine and what happened in Bosnia.

Truth.

2014-03-04 10:14 AM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Pro
5755
50005001001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Does anyone think Russia is handling the situation reasonably well, all things considered? I have the impression we would have been bombing by now.



2014-03-04 10:25 AM
in reply to: BrianRunsPhilly

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by BrianRunsPhilly

Does anyone think Russia is handling the situation reasonably well, all things considered? I have the impression we would have been bombing by now.

Russia created the problem, make no mistake about that.  What Putin is doing is playing his game very well. Like I said earlier.....if he stops at with the Crimean peninsula there may be no blowblack at all.....but if he gets greedy there will be problems IMO.  So yeah, in that regard, he's handled it well......but I'd bet this has been in the works as a contingency for some time.

 

2014-03-04 11:04 AM
in reply to: tuwood

User image

Master
2802
2000500100100100
Minnetonka, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: Ukraine
"Putin blinks, stocks rally: Ukraine crisis shows power of global markets

European economies, most notably Germany's, would indeed be at risk if the Ukrainian crisis worsens: Germany gets more than one-third of its natural gas from Russia and is Russia's third-largest trading partner, The WSJ reports. If the Germany economy sneezes, the rest of Europe would almost certainly catch a cold -- and likely tip back into recession after the EU economy finally seems to be regain its footing.

But the reality is that Russia has the most to lose economically from a prolonged showdown with the West. This was starkly evident in Monday's 10% decline in its major equity index and the ruble's fall to record lows vs the dollar and euro, prompting a rate hike from the Russian Central Bank to stabilize the currency.

It appears Putin heeded the market's unadulterated and instant reaction to Russia's provocation in Crimea. If nothing else, Putin is very good at protecting his personal interests and must know that economic instability in Russia isn't good for his long-term prospects -- financial or political.

..."


All saber rattling I hope!
2014-03-15 11:43 PM
in reply to: 0

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: Ukraine

They elected a weak leader who was compromised by Putin......he's still KGB at his core and longs for the days of the Soviet Union, no?   The Ukranians and the world may be better served to cut their losses and move on.

"elected" yeah... this is the same guy that had his first (fradulent) election nullified after the Orange revolution, and won in 2010 under similar dubious circumstances.  Very, very corrupt, and a puppet of Russia.

The division between Russian and Ukrainian speakers - that's just something the Western press likes to play up.  Everyone there pretty much speaks both, and some words / phrases are mixed and matched.  There's not this constant animosity that the media would have you believe.  As for the media THERE, it's mostly owned by oligarchs and it's a constant barrage of propaganda one way or the other.  It makes MSNBC and Fox look like buddies.  You think politics are tough in the U.S. - heh... it's a full contact sport in Ukraine and Russia.

Putin is playing up the "facism / nazi" card in the eastern regions to undermine Kyiv.  But Ukrainians have a long memory and I think even in Donetsk and Kharkiv, they'd rather work with Russia than be absorbed by Russia.  Read up on Holodomor, the demolition of St. Michael's cathedral, deportation of Tatars from Crimea, etc.  There's a lot of resentment that won't go away with a rigged vote or a few Russian controlled tv stations.

My girlfriend is Ukrainian and we were there in Kyiv last June, so I have a little different perspective on what's happening.



Edited by spudone 2014-03-15 11:45 PM
2014-03-16 12:22 AM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by spudone

They elected a weak leader who was compromised by Putin......he's still KGB at his core and longs for the days of the Soviet Union, no?   The Ukranians and the world may be better served to cut their losses and move on.

"elected" yeah... this is the same guy that had his first (fradulent) election nullified after the Orange revolution, and won in 2010 under similar dubious circumstances.  Very, very corrupt, and a puppet of Russia.

The division between Russian and Ukrainian speakers - that's just something the Western press likes to play up.  Everyone there pretty much speaks both, and some words / phrases are mixed and matched.  There's not this constant animosity that the media would have you believe.  As for the media THERE, it's mostly owned by oligarchs and it's a constant barrage of propaganda one way or the other.  It makes MSNBC and Fox look like buddies.  You think politics are tough in the U.S. - heh... it's a full contact sport in Ukraine and Russia.

Putin is playing up the "facism / nazi" card in the eastern regions to undermine Kyiv.  But Ukrainians have a long memory and I think even in Donetsk and Kharkiv, they'd rather work with Russia than be absorbed by Russia.  Read up on Holodomor, the demolition of St. Michael's cathedral, deportation of Tatars from Crimea, etc.  There's a lot of resentment that won't go away with a rigged vote or a few Russian controlled tv stations.

My girlfriend is Ukrainian and we were there in Kyiv last June, so I have a little different perspective on what's happening.

Eh....I'm not downplaying your GF's perspective, but the fact is, there are quite a few Ukrainians here, along with others from the region.....and quite a few have settled near where I live...along with my interest in that region of the world due to my own heritage.  The Crimean peninsula will go to Russia....watch and see....and the world will stand down if that's as far as it goes.

I'm not saying it's right or wrong......it's just the easiest way.....Putin has long known this.

2014-03-16 12:28 AM
in reply to: Left Brain

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by spudone

They elected a weak leader who was compromised by Putin......he's still KGB at his core and longs for the days of the Soviet Union, no?   The Ukranians and the world may be better served to cut their losses and move on.

"elected" yeah... this is the same guy that had his first (fradulent) election nullified after the Orange revolution, and won in 2010 under similar dubious circumstances.  Very, very corrupt, and a puppet of Russia.

The division between Russian and Ukrainian speakers - that's just something the Western press likes to play up.  Everyone there pretty much speaks both, and some words / phrases are mixed and matched.  There's not this constant animosity that the media would have you believe.  As for the media THERE, it's mostly owned by oligarchs and it's a constant barrage of propaganda one way or the other.  It makes MSNBC and Fox look like buddies.  You think politics are tough in the U.S. - heh... it's a full contact sport in Ukraine and Russia.

Putin is playing up the "facism / nazi" card in the eastern regions to undermine Kyiv.  But Ukrainians have a long memory and I think even in Donetsk and Kharkiv, they'd rather work with Russia than be absorbed by Russia.  Read up on Holodomor, the demolition of St. Michael's cathedral, deportation of Tatars from Crimea, etc.  There's a lot of resentment that won't go away with a rigged vote or a few Russian controlled tv stations.

My girlfriend is Ukrainian and we were there in Kyiv last June, so I have a little different perspective on what's happening.

Eh....I'm not downplaying your GF's perspective, but the fact is, there are quite a few Ukrainians here, along with others from the region.....and quite a few have settled near where I live...along with my interest in that region of the world due to my own heritage.  The Crimean peninsula will go to Russia....watch and see....and the world will stand down if that's as far as it goes.

I'm not saying it's right or wrong......it's just the easiest way.....Putin has long known this.

It really depends on whether Russia's uber-rich continue to support Putin or not.  He'll get it in the short term.  Long term will depend mostly on Germany and who's willing to hold out the longest in a trade war.

Turkey could also be a factor as they will not want Russia dominating the Black Sea.



2014-03-16 11:13 AM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by spudone

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by spudone

They elected a weak leader who was compromised by Putin......he's still KGB at his core and longs for the days of the Soviet Union, no?   The Ukranians and the world may be better served to cut their losses and move on.

"elected" yeah... this is the same guy that had his first (fradulent) election nullified after the Orange revolution, and won in 2010 under similar dubious circumstances.  Very, very corrupt, and a puppet of Russia.

The division between Russian and Ukrainian speakers - that's just something the Western press likes to play up.  Everyone there pretty much speaks both, and some words / phrases are mixed and matched.  There's not this constant animosity that the media would have you believe.  As for the media THERE, it's mostly owned by oligarchs and it's a constant barrage of propaganda one way or the other.  It makes MSNBC and Fox look like buddies.  You think politics are tough in the U.S. - heh... it's a full contact sport in Ukraine and Russia.

Putin is playing up the "facism / nazi" card in the eastern regions to undermine Kyiv.  But Ukrainians have a long memory and I think even in Donetsk and Kharkiv, they'd rather work with Russia than be absorbed by Russia.  Read up on Holodomor, the demolition of St. Michael's cathedral, deportation of Tatars from Crimea, etc.  There's a lot of resentment that won't go away with a rigged vote or a few Russian controlled tv stations.

My girlfriend is Ukrainian and we were there in Kyiv last June, so I have a little different perspective on what's happening.

Eh....I'm not downplaying your GF's perspective, but the fact is, there are quite a few Ukrainians here, along with others from the region.....and quite a few have settled near where I live...along with my interest in that region of the world due to my own heritage.  The Crimean peninsula will go to Russia....watch and see....and the world will stand down if that's as far as it goes.

I'm not saying it's right or wrong......it's just the easiest way.....Putin has long known this.

It really depends on whether Russia's uber-rich continue to support Putin or not.  He'll get it in the short term.  Long term will depend mostly on Germany and who's willing to hold out the longest in a trade war.

Turkey could also be a factor as they will not want Russia dominating the Black Sea.

They will for Crimea......any further push by him and maybe/probably not.  Putin's a sharp guy playing a chess match.....all he did was make a move he knew he could make.

2014-03-17 10:05 AM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Pro
9391
500020002000100100100252525
Omaha, NE
Subject: RE: Ukraine

I hear a lot about economic sanctions and trade wars to try and get Russia back "in line", but is this really a viable weapon.  I'll admit I don't know a ton about their economy, but I think they export a lot more than they import and Iran and China will certainly side with them in the long run.

2014-03-17 10:44 AM
in reply to: tuwood

User image

Pro
9391
500020002000100100100252525
Omaha, NE
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

2014-03-17 4:01 PM
in reply to: 0

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by tuwood

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

I can't imagine a man of Putin's background takes Obama seriously about anything.  The Russian market is probably laughing as well.



Edited by Left Brain 2014-03-17 4:01 PM
2014-03-17 4:30 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Deep in the Heart of Texas
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by tuwood

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

I can't imagine a man of Putin's background takes Obama seriously about anything.  The Russian market is probably laughing as well.

No, now go away or I shall taunt you a second time. (spoken with Russian as opposed to French accent)



2014-03-17 6:56 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

Master
5557
50005002525
, California
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by tuwood

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

I can't imagine a man of Putin's background takes Obama seriously about anything.  The Russian market is probably laughing as well.

In fairness, Ukraine should've required NATO membership as a condition of giving up their nukes.  That would've put the U.S. and EU into a situation that *required* their attention, rather than just words.

2014-03-17 7:33 PM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by spudone

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by tuwood

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

I can't imagine a man of Putin's background takes Obama seriously about anything.  The Russian market is probably laughing as well.

In fairness, Ukraine should've required NATO membership as a condition of giving up their nukes.  That would've put the U.S. and EU into a situation that *required* their attention, rather than just words.

Yeah, that's a good call, but we're not there.  As it stands, we have a very small hammer, and very small words.....and Putin knows it.

2014-03-18 8:11 AM
in reply to: spudone

User image

Pro
9391
500020002000100100100252525
Omaha, NE
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Originally posted by spudone

Originally posted by Left Brain

Originally posted by tuwood

Mental note, if your sanctions cause their markets to rally then you're probably not going far enough.  

Report: Weak White House Sanctions Rally Russian Market

I can't imagine a man of Putin's background takes Obama seriously about anything.  The Russian market is probably laughing as well.

In fairness, Ukraine should've required NATO membership as a condition of giving up their nukes.  That would've put the U.S. and EU into a situation that *required* their attention, rather than just words.

I don't disagree, but I seriously question the will of NATO or the US for that matter engaging militarily with Russia.  With the size of Russia's economy I would even question the ability of NATO to impose strong sanctions against Russia.  It would be like the world sanctioning the US.  It would likely result in far more pain worldwide than it would here.  So, unless somebody (cough, the US) is willing to go toe to toe with Russia then they will do whatever they want.

2014-03-20 1:51 PM
in reply to: tuwood

User image

Master
2946
200050010010010010025
Centennial, CO
Subject: RE: Ukraine

Love it.  Now that Obama has "Sanctioned" reps from Russia, Putin turns around and sanctions our reps.  You really showed him Obama.  

Any thoughts?  I thought the sanctions were silly, apparently Russia agrees with me.

 

 

New Thread
Other Resources The Political Joe » Ukraine Rss Feed  
 
 
of 3