General Discussion Gear Reviews & Questions » Which watch should I get? Rss Feed  
Moderators: the bear, Ron Reply
2014-03-11 8:33 AM

User image

Extreme Veteran
950
5001001001001002525
Collierville, Tennessee
Silver member
Subject: Which watch should I get?
I currently have a Garmin 310XT, and really like it, but I'd like to track my pool swims. So, what should I do?

1. Get a Garmin Swim
2. Get a 910XT and get rid of my 310XT
3. Get the Garmin Fenix2, which just came out

Any thoughts are appreciated!


2014-03-11 10:01 AM
in reply to: 0

User image

Extreme Veteran
498
100100100100252525
Northbrook
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
Depends on what you are planning on doing with it. If its just for the pool, get a specific swimming watch. If you are planning on using it for the run and bike, then i would suggest 910XT.

I have the 910XT. Works great in the pool. I have the Swimovate pool mate watch also which I used before I got the 910XT. Both do what promised. From my experience, 910XT, adds a pool length once in a while but thats not a big problem.

No experience with Garmin Swim or Fenix2.

Good luck and let us know what you decided.

Edited by Maks Tri 2014-03-11 10:02 AM
2014-03-11 10:11 AM
in reply to: WoodrowCall

User image

Expert
957
5001001001001002525
Albuquerque, NM
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
I go for option #2.
Everything you need in one watch.
2014-03-11 11:51 AM
in reply to: WoodrowCall

User image

Regular
128
10025
Ankeny
Gold member
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
If it were me, today, I'd most likely go with the 910XT.

That being said, DC Rainmaker gives an excellent "First Look" at the Fenix2 here: http://www.dcrainmaker.com/2014/02/garmin-fenix2-multisport-triathl...

There's also a comparison chart at the bottom of the review for the two devices. They both retail for the same price. I don't think you could go wrong either way.
2014-03-11 6:58 PM
in reply to: WoodrowCall


2

Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
Hi,

I am in a product development class at Lehigh University, in Bethlehem, PA. My group is actually working on an activity tracking bracelet (like a Nike Fuel Band) designed specifically to measure swimming metrics. I would love to get some insider info about what triathaloners would think of the product. I would be beyond grateful if you were willing to take a short survey (only 10 questions!) about the product. Here is the link: https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/PCJBVSN

Thanks so much!
2014-03-12 12:03 PM
in reply to: WoodrowCall

User image

Elite
3033
2000100025
N Carolina
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
Buy a 910xt and it will be the only Multisport device you will ever need. Also, if you can, buy it from REI, and their return/exchange policy will be there for you if the Garmin warranty doesn't work in your favor.


2014-03-12 12:24 PM
in reply to: WoodrowCall

User image

Pro
5051
50002525
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?

I've gone Suunto- and have been very happy with my Ambit2.

it has been very accurate tracking swim laps- and easy to use.  if you stop for more than 5 seconds, it automatically considers your set done and gives you set metrics (if you choose to display them).  Then just continue on.  I've found that the 910xt tends not to show you the right number of laps- until you're done with the set.  A little annoying.

other nice thing about going Suunto... in 3 months their website (movescount) has never been down for maintenance or otherwise off line for me.  Garmin's site is always going down, and gets really annoying.  

Another nice thing about the Suunto- the watch is stable.  unlike my Garmin, it has never frozen or blanked out on me.  it just works.  Oh, and there are apps for everything. Like- I ran an ultra a couple weeks ago, and uploaded an app that was continuously calculating my 50mi finish time based on my pace and distance, or I went skiing a few weeks ago, and there's an app that counts ski runs, vertical, average and max speed for the run... stuff like that.

If you need a "Swim/Bike/Run" watch- the 910xt is still the leader in those specific features I guess.

if you want a watch (er... the 910 isn't a watch) that you can wear every day and always have on your wrist for that lunch run/swim/bike, then the Ambit2 makes sense.  you can also program any number of sports into it.  special apps for skiing, sailing, whatever you can think of- each named and picked off a list.  You control what is available on the watch through their web based program.  Plus the navigation features are more like the Fenix (except more stable).

Dowside of the Suunto- there are a few things that the Garmin 910 will do that the Ambit2 won't.  Specifically:  1. Complex custom workouts.  2. Vibration Alarm. 3. real time power metrics- such as TSS, IP, Np (it will pick up an ANT+ power meter and display power, just doesn't calculate the metrics in real time, you'd need to upload to get them)

So- just throwing it out there as another option.

Suunto makes a very nice product.

2014-03-12 12:49 PM
in reply to: WoodrowCall

User image

Expert
2057
20002525
Greenville, SC
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?

get the swim for now and wait on the 920xt to come out sometime this year.  that way you can sell me your lightly used swim at a discount and get a much nicer multisport watch. 

2014-03-12 2:08 PM
in reply to: Clempson

User image

Extreme Veteran
950
5001001001001002525
Collierville, Tennessee
Silver member
Subject: RE: Which watch should I get?
Thanks for the input, everybody, especially Kyle! I'm going to get the Garmin Swim at REI. If I like it enough, then I'll hang onto it. If not, I'm a member at REI and they have a really great return policy, so I can get the 920, or the Fenix 2, which looks pretty sweet. Thanks for all the advice!
New Thread
General Discussion Gear Reviews & Questions » Which watch should I get? Rss Feed  
RELATED POSTS

Need A Basic Watch

Started by mommy22boys
Views: 443 Posts: 2

2005-01-10 6:13 PM JGFTri

heart rate moniter/mp3 player/stop watch recommendations

Started by lizzy_nyc
Views: 768 Posts: 4

2004-12-01 8:51 AM jimtri

Timex 66801 Ironman Triathlon watch

Started by satchmo72
Views: 680 Posts: 1

2004-09-16 11:12 AM satchmo72

Timex 5C401 HRM (& Ironman Watch)

Started by glf33
Views: 969 Posts: 4

2004-10-06 7:09 PM FIN16

Timex Ironman Watches

Started by mikenhe
Views: 1542 Posts: 20

2004-02-12 3:45 AM JaWaLav
RELATED ARTICLES
date : October 21, 2011
author : Scott Tinley
comments : 0
Part Three: What's Reality Got to Do with Anything Old?
 
date : September 16, 2011
author : Scott Tinley
comments : 0
Part Two: On Appreciation and Acceptance. At some point your body will let you down. Then you have to decide whether it is really the enemy.
date : August 19, 2011
author : Scott Tinley
comments : 1
Part One: On Speed, Desire and Age. There are some advantages to running slowly. Now, give me a minute here and I'll try to think of one.
 
date : December 12, 2009
author : FitWerx
comments : 0
We are often asked the question, "What size frame should I buy" and the answer is “it depends”. I know that’s not the answer you want to hear, but hopefully the following will shed some more light.
date : September 10, 2009
author : Amy Kuitse
comments : 3
Should I be working on getting faster at running by doing the longer distances and working up slowly over time or run faster for shorter distances now?
 
date : May 12, 2009
author : mat steinmetz
comments : 0
I'm too slow for some group rides and of course I want to increase it for races. What exercise/training should I be focusing on?
date : September 15, 2008
author : lcthomas74
comments : 0
Soon after I got married, I decided I needed to get motivated to work out and focus on getting back into shape. I could barely jog a quarter-mile without needing a walk break.
 
date : July 8, 2008
author : amyro1234
comments : 0
Ever since I was 11 years old and first heard the word "triathlon" mentioned, I have made it my vow to do one. But what 11 year old does triathlons?”