Subject: RE: Cycling Workouts on the TrainerShort comparison between Spinervals and Carmichael's tapes.
The GOOD: Carmichael seems to have a very speciifc goal for each tape and reviews the perspective rewards. He gives a very good warm up and a good cool down. Good back ground music and even entertaining with shots of different races during the work outs.
The bad: Hard to check the gearing used and not everyione has a power tap.
I really like the three Carmichael work outs I have done, Hills, TT and Sprints. Overall they are all high quality productions. The later ones better productioin quality.
Only done one of the Spinervals so far. # 5.0..."Mental toughness" 1.5 hrs. long. Easy to understand the gearing used but not as specific as it could be for power or HR. Not specific as it might be to the reasoning behind the workout and the perspective gains, besides "mental toughness" which is a bit Loose IMO for a 1.5 hr workout. 5.0 is a good tape for the beginner wanting to learn how to run his gears though. Warm up and cool down I htink could be done much better, but then I ma an old guy and beed a good warm up and cool.
I have 4 more Spinervals to go before I can give a better review and comparison between the two series. |