General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Trainer...Road or TT Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2010-10-17 1:00 PM

User image

Expert
1104
1000100
Canada
Subject: Trainer...Road or TT
If you have a Road bike & tri bike & use a trainer for the winter...Which do you put on trainer?

Is there difference?  I expect the mantra of "use the bike you use most" applies.

Undecided 


2010-10-17 1:33 PM
in reply to: #3156528

Veteran
268
1001002525
Boulder
Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
I am going to preface this with the fact that I believe most people who ride tri bikes (including myself) spend a lot of time out-of-aero. Read the article entitled "Why You Need a Road Bike": http://iamspecialized.com/triathlon/rider/jordan-rapp#/blog

And this is what brings us to the really real reason that you need a road bike.

Whenever you are NOT in your aerobars, you would better off on a road bike.

The reason for this has to do entirely with biomechanics. People who primarily ride their tribikes use the following argument, "I race on my tribike, so I should train on my tribike." While this is true, most people do race in their aerobars.
  • ..
  • So what this means is that every time you come up out of your aerobars, you are training in a position that is VERY different from the one you want to race in. And, ironically, in these moments, were you riding a road bike, it would be your position on that bike that would be most similar to the position you aim to race your tribike in. This is the position that will allow you to generate the most power, recruit the most musculature, and be the most comfortable. But you need to train in this position.


    That said and accounted for, remember that any time on the trainer is better than no time on the trainer. If you're comfortable on your tri bike, throw that one on the trainer. If you're comfortable on the road bike, that's fine.

    Edited by persondude27 2010-10-17 1:33 PM
    2010-10-18 2:45 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Extreme Veteran
    501
    500
    Northbrook
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    TT bike for me, just get into a comfortable aero position, if you got one and spin for hours. 
    2010-10-18 2:57 AM
    in reply to: #3156552

    User image

    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    persondude27 - 2010-10-17 2:33 PM

    I am going to preface this with the fact that I believe most people who ride tri bikes (including myself) spend a lot of time out-of-aero.


    That's why you should use your tri bike on the trainer as well, to quit coming out of aero. Unless you're braking or climbing to the point of being in small chainring and lowest gear you should be down in your aero bars. Get used to it.
    2010-10-18 4:37 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Master
    2491
    2000100100100100252525
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    My road bike goes on the trainer. It's more comfortable. The steeper angle of the TT bike is tougher on the shoulders and neck, and I don't really need to be aero while just sitting there in front of my fan.
    2010-10-18 8:51 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Pro
    5011
    5000
    Twin Cities
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    When it's not racing season, I usually keep the tri bike on the trainer. I prefer to do most of my road riding on my road bike. And I like the TT bike on the trainer, b/c then I can set my kindle on the aerobars. :-) (Plus, it gives me a few more options for hand positions...bull horns, no hands, in aero, etc.)


    2010-10-18 8:57 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Pro
    6582
    50001000500252525
    Melbourne FL
    Gold member
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    I don't have a RB but if I did I'd but the bike that I race with on the trainer, TB.
    2010-10-18 11:03 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Expert
    1007
    1000
    NW NJ
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    On the trainer, I'm faster in aero on the TT!  
    2010-10-18 11:06 AM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Extreme Veteran
    590
    500252525
    Seattle
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    tri bike, i generally ride the road bike more in the spring (outdoors) so this balances it out.
    2010-10-18 2:59 PM
    in reply to: #3156552

    User image

    Champion
    11989
    500050001000500100100100100252525
    Philly 'burbs
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    persondude27 - 2010-10-17 2:33 PM I am going to preface this with the fact that I believe most people who ride tri bikes (including myself) spend a lot of time out-of-aero. Read the article entitled "Why You Need a Road Bike": http://iamspecialized.com/triathlon/rider/jordan-rapp#/blog
    And this is what brings us to the really real reason that you need a road bike. Whenever you are NOT in your aerobars, you would better off on a road bike. The reason for this has to do entirely with biomechanics. People who primarily ride their tribikes use the following argument, "I race on my tribike, so I should train on my tribike." While this is true, most people do race in their aerobars. ... So what this means is that every time you come up out of your aerobars, you are training in a position that is VERY different from the one you want to race in. And, ironically, in these moments, were you riding a road bike, it would be your position on that bike that would be most similar to the position you aim to race your tribike in. This is the position that will allow you to generate the most power, recruit the most musculature, and be the most comfortable. But you need to train in this position.
    That said and accounted for, remember that any time on the trainer is better than no time on the trainer. If you're comfortable on your tri bike, throw that one on the trainer. If you're comfortable on the road bike, that's fine.


    Every race I've ever done I've come out of aero when I've had to. Same with training rides.
    2010-10-18 3:02 PM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    Veteran
    693
    500100252525
    Indianapolis
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    TT. Train like you race (hopefully).


    2010-10-18 3:04 PM
    in reply to: #3156528

    User image

    over a barrier
    Subject: RE: Trainer...Road or TT
    Road bike. I work the entire power profile over the winter, which is easier on the road bike.

    I never ride aero on the trainer, just outside.
    New Thread
    General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Trainer...Road or TT Rss Feed