General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices? Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2012-02-09 10:47 AM

New user
33
25
Hollis, NH
Subject: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

I live in NH and have been doing sprint and olympic triathlons for the past few years and want to do a half ironman this summer or next summer.  I own a road bike and want to get a tri bike at some point.  I do this for fun to stay in shape, I usually place between the MOP and BOP.  I had a bike fit performed on me and they recommended these bikes:

Specialized Transition XL 2010/2011

Blue T14 L

Argon 18 L

Cannondale Slice 58

Kuota K Factor L

Orbea Ordu 57

Trek Speed Concept L

 

I am overwhelmed at the thought of researching these to figure out what bike to get.  I don’t want to buy the most obscure bike because when the day comes that I decide to upgrade or sell my bike, I want to make sure there is a market to sell it.  I also don’t need to get the fastest most expensive bike.  I certainly want to improve, but if a $5000 bike make me a minute faster than a $3000 bike then I want to get the $3000 bike.  Basically I want to get the one that gives me the most bang for my buck.

Could someone make a recommendation?  Or at least eliminate some bikes and give me
the top three options?

I really appreciate the help!



2012-02-09 10:55 AM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Extreme Veteran
543
50025
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

well, for someone tht doesn't want to reaserch a good determinant would be which brand your local pro shop is affiliated with, mine is Cdale. i would personally investigate the specialized, cannondale, and trek orbea would be next, there all gonna be great bikes keep an eye out for deals on all of them

good luck

2012-02-09 11:02 AM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Master
2725
200050010010025
Washington, DC Metro
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

My personal opinion is that any of the listed bikes will be more than sufficient for your needs, and better than ridding a roadie (i.e. aero benefits).  So I would get the one that I found at the best deal, from the best/closest/friendliest shop.  You will likely find that the C-dale, Trek, and Specialized are the most easily found, as they are the most prominent brands on your list.  So you may be able to pick from multiple LBS for these brands.

Word of caution on the Kuota, IIRC they are not in the US market anymore so if you find a left over model somewhere you might find a great deal, but have some difficulty if there is a warranty issue with the frame or whatever.

2012-02-09 11:44 AM
in reply to: #4038069

User image

Elite
3060
200010002525
N Carolina
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
Sous - 2012-02-09 12:02 PM

My personal opinion is that any of the listed bikes will be more than sufficient for your needs, and better than ridding a roadie (i.e. aero benefits).  So I would get the one that I found at the best deal, from the best/closest/friendliest shop.  You will likely find that the C-dale, Trek, and Specialized are the most easily found, as they are the most prominent brands on your list.  So you may be able to pick from multiple LBS for these brands.

Word of caution on the Kuota, IIRC they are not in the US market anymore so if you find a left over model somewhere you might find a great deal, but have some difficulty if there is a warranty issue with the frame or whatever.

x2.  I'm going into my 3rd season on my Kuota K Factor.  Although I've been satisfied with my bike and I've done a full IM on it, I wish I had done more research before I bought it.

The Trek Speed Concept is one of the hot bikes now and the resale market should be good for it later on.

2012-02-09 11:51 AM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Veteran
149
10025
Toronto, Canada
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

Here is what I would choose in order:

Trek SC

Specialized Transition

Cannondale Slice

Orbea Ordu

My order is based on re-sale and looks.  I assume that all components would be similar (or very close) and they all fit exactly the same on you.

If there is one that would fit better than another...then that would be choice #1

2012-02-09 12:03 PM
in reply to: #4038018


76
252525
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
if you're looking for bang for your buck, just troll classifieds on here, ST, and ebay until a used one pops up for a great deal.


2012-02-09 12:22 PM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Extreme Veteran
845
50010010010025
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

I am like Kinger18 I had a bike fitting and they gave me a list of bikes that would most likely fit me the best.  I have narrowed the choices down to two as two of my LBS carry them.

Felt B12 or the Cervelo P2.  I can get them both at the same price.  I have test rode the Felt B16 bike and that felt good, haven't had a chance to ride the Cervelo yet.  If you were in my shoes, which one would you buy?

2012-02-09 12:43 PM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Veteran
222
100100
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
B12 and P2? I believe the package on the B12 is better... And from a visual perspective, I like the felt... I just bought a P2 on the share he ride deal and I was strongly considering the B16... If I could have picked up a B12 for the price I paid for the P2 it would have been a no brainer to grab the Felt. But I was $500 less than the B16 so it made sense, and the Cervelo is a little better fit for ME.
2012-02-09 12:49 PM
in reply to: #4038018

New user
33
25
Hollis, NH
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?

Thanks for all the responses, I really appreciate the help!  I have been trolling classifieds and anything i find would have to be purchased sight unseen and shipped to me.  This scares me a little which is why i posted.  The responses here will help me pull the trigger if something looks good. 

The speed concept prices new seem very reasonable.  I have to research the differences between 7.0, 7.5, and 9.0 etc.  There is a LBS that carries them a half an hr away.  I might head over there now to learn more about them.

Thanks again!



Edited by kinger18 2012-02-09 12:51 PM
2012-02-09 2:25 PM
in reply to: #4038296

User image

Master
2725
200050010010025
Washington, DC Metro
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
krazytallchick - 2012-02-09 1:22 PM

I am like Kinger18 I had a bike fitting and they gave me a list of bikes that would most likely fit me the best.  I have narrowed the choices down to two as two of my LBS carry them.

Felt B12 or the Cervelo P2.  I can get them both at the same price.  I have test rode the Felt B16 bike and that felt good, haven't had a chance to ride the Cervelo yet.  If you were in my shoes, which one would you buy?

Hijack aside Wink I ride a B12 and love it.  Not that the P2 is a bad bike by any means, but for me I think the B12 is a tick nicer, I like the look better, and lastly its much eaiser to find in T1.... P2, P2, P1, P2, P2, QRoo, P2... oh there's my Felt!

2012-02-09 3:18 PM
in reply to: #4038296

User image

Veteran
149
10025
Toronto, Canada
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
I'm biased and have a Felt B14 so I would choose the Felt Tongue out


2012-02-09 4:02 PM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Extreme Veteran
337
10010010025
Houston
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
competitive cyclist has some pretty good deals on the ordu...its what i would get lol
2012-02-09 4:05 PM
in reply to: #4038018

User image

Veteran
204
100100
Massapequa, NY
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
i have a 2011 trek SC 7.5 and i absolutely love it.  Go with the best fit at the most affordable for you.  you wont end your spending at the bike purchase!
2012-02-09 4:11 PM
in reply to: #4038296

User image

Pro
5361
50001001001002525
Subject: RE: Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices?
krazytallchick - 2012-02-09 10:22 AM

Felt B12 or the Cervelo P2.  I can get them both at the same price.  I have test rode the Felt B16 bike and that felt good, haven't had a chance to ride the Cervelo yet.  If you were in my shoes, which one would you buy?

the B12 has the better component spec, and you get wheels that you can race with if you want.  The P2 has a slightly more aero frame it seems; although moving your head up or down 2cm will amount to 10x the difference in the frame aero.  Plus, between the wheels and the cockpit on the B12- it's almost assuredly the faster bike as is.    If you're planning on getting aero race wheels anyway, and don't mind having the same bike as everyone else - then you couldn't go wrong with the P2. 

whatever you decide- there are no wrong choices here.  both are fine steeds that can take you to the podium.

2012-02-09 4:12 PM
in reply to: #4038772

Subject: ...
This user's post has been ignored.
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Can you help me narrow down my tri bike choices? Rss Feed