General Discussion Triathlon Talk » How much can I still gain in fitness? Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
2012-05-24 10:58 AM

User image

Champion
10018
50005000
, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: How much can I still gain in fitness?

I have an Olympic tri on June 3rd and I am worried about my current fitness.  I'll finish fine, but I probably won't reach my goal (sub-3).  I can understand that, I made my choices.

I am usually a big fan of the taper and extra rest has worked well for me, but I suddenly find myself wanting to cram in a bunch of mileage by the end of the Memorial Day weekend.

Is there any point to that?  Will a good couple of swims this weekend really impact my performance positively the weekend after?  Do you see any harm in working my little heart out this weekend in all three sports?



2012-05-24 11:00 AM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Veteran
246
10010025
Edwards AFB
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
I never know what folks will say, but I say no.  At this point being refreshed and ready to race (and not tired or over-worked) is your best bet.
2012-05-24 11:02 AM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Master
2563
20005002525
University Park, MD
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

I think there is still time to make some gains - both in fitness and in confidence. A week should be plenty of time to allow for positive adaptation to the training, as long as you don't push yourself so hard that you struggle to recover in the intervening week. Better to avoid doing too much more than you've been doing lately.

The two-week taper is more in order in a situation where somebody has a huge IM-like quantity of training to recover from.

2012-05-24 11:03 AM
in reply to: #4227237

User image

Extreme Veteran
391
100100100252525
Torrance, CA
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

If you're sure you'll finish - then no. 

None of the training you do will result in any significant gains for what you're trying to accomplish.  A week out - either you're going to finish at your goal or you're not.

Just try as hard as you can, go out and race your race.  Chances are, you'll surprise yourself.  Worst case scenario, the result will motivate you to train harder to reach goal at your next race.

2012-05-24 11:57 AM
in reply to: #4227228

Master
10208
50005000100100
Northern IL
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
You can still get some solid training in over the weekend and recover well enough to race for the next. Just make sure that you're not reaching for your ability. Stay below where you would have to take a little time off or a number of easy days to recover.
2012-05-24 12:02 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Expert
2192
2000100252525
Greenville, SC
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
a couple of good swims might not improve your performance, but it may give you some extra confidence which will improve your ability to perform.  


2012-05-24 12:59 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Veteran
740
50010010025
The Woodlands, TX
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

My perspective as a lousy swimmer who's struggling to become MOP is that swimming 3 to 4 times a week in the week or two before the race can have a HUGE impact. I agree that fitness gains are not going to happen, but my swim limiter is not fitness, its technique. I have not had enough swim time to engrain good technique into my muscle memory. As a result, if I have not been swimming much, it takes me some time in the pool to get BOP to MOP technique. If I just show up on race day I'll be back of the pack. If I swim 4 or 5 times in the week or two before the race, I'll be MOP.

I don't see the same relative improvements from biking or running. If it were me, I'd swim my little heart out, bike good and hard this wekend, but take it easy with the running.

2012-05-24 1:19 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Master
2563
20005002525
University Park, MD
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

I feel the need to disagree here with the view that fitness gains can't be had in a short period. Fitness gains are the adaptations that happen during recovery from training. So if you can recover in time, then you can gain fitness in time. Perhaps not a whole lot, but enough to make some difference. 

(Please somebody jump in to correct me here if I'm wrong about the coupling of recovery and adaptations.)

2012-05-24 1:24 PM
in reply to: #4227553

User image

Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
colinphillips - 2012-05-24 8:19 AM

I feel the need to disagree here with the view that fitness gains can't be had in a short period. Fitness gains are the adaptations that happen during recovery from training. So if you can recover in time, then you can gain fitness in time. Perhaps not a whole lot, but enough to make some difference. 

(Please somebody jump in to correct me here if I'm wrong about the coupling of recovery and adaptations.)

I agree.  It just depends on the individual how well they recover from specific workouts.

2012-05-24 1:25 PM
in reply to: #4227553

User image

Champion
10018
50005000
, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
colinphillips - 2012-05-24 1:19 PM

I feel the need to disagree here with the view that fitness gains can't be had in a short period. Fitness gains are the adaptations that happen during recovery from training. So if you can recover in time, then you can gain fitness in time. Perhaps not a whole lot, but enough to make some difference. 

(Please somebody jump in to correct me here if I'm wrong about the coupling of recovery and adaptations.)

I agree with you - really my question is what is the length of that period?  Is a week too short?  Frankly I think I will gain the most from biking and running at this point (swimming for years and nothing much changes).    I know I would need Carnac to tell me if I could recover in time, but there must be some guidelines.  

2012-05-24 1:31 PM
in reply to: #4227366

User image

Master
2167
20001002525
Livonia, MI
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

Clempson - 2012-05-24 1:02 PM a couple of good swims might not improve your performance, but it may give you some extra confidence which will improve your ability to perform.  

This is what I was thinking.  For me, racing is such a mental game.  My mindset has an impact on my performance just as my physical preparedness does.  If you *feel* just a bit more prepared, that can make the difference to go just a bit faster.



2012-05-24 1:36 PM
in reply to: #4227553

Master
10208
50005000100100
Northern IL
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
colinphillips - 2012-05-24 1:19 PM

I feel the need to disagree here with the view that fitness gains can't be had in a short period. Fitness gains are the adaptations that happen during recovery from training. So if you can recover in time, then you can gain fitness in time. Perhaps not a whole lot, but enough to make some difference. 

(Please somebody jump in to correct me here if I'm wrong about the coupling of recovery and adaptations.)

I think they can be had too, but it's more question if they're that detectable over this short of a time period for someone who has been active at least pretty regular for some time. Above I said to go ahead and do stuff this weekend, but be mindful of how much and how hard it is. There is the balance of recovering enough to do a solid workout again, and there is the intent of the taper to have the bit of a boost for race day.

I have a HIM that same day and am planning some things this weekend too, like 10 mile TT Sat, a 60 mile or so ride on Sunday, some swimming & med-long run Monday. I know I'll recover well from those and get that boost for race day in the last few days before the race of doing virtually nothing. Now if I went for a century ride all 3 days or tried to do a 2.5-3 hr long run this weekend, I could recover to go hard again by next weekend, but I wouldn't have the race I'd like. That's where I'd need to be careful of "cramming" for a race. And I know about where this is from watching all the training I've been doing the last few years. For bikergrrrrl, it's the same idea, but maybe different limitations on the volume & intensity.

I'm also thinking longer term and how much working out I'd miss if I did a drawn out taper like most do. Not every race has to be optimized perfectly.

2012-05-24 1:37 PM
in reply to: #4227570

User image

Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
BikerGrrrl - 2012-05-24 8:25 AM
colinphillips - 2012-05-24 1:19 PM

I feel the need to disagree here with the view that fitness gains can't be had in a short period. Fitness gains are the adaptations that happen during recovery from training. So if you can recover in time, then you can gain fitness in time. Perhaps not a whole lot, but enough to make some difference. 

(Please somebody jump in to correct me here if I'm wrong about the coupling of recovery and adaptations.)

I agree with you - really my question is what is the length of that period?  Is a week too short?  Frankly I think I will gain the most from biking and running at this point (swimming for years and nothing much changes).    I know I would need Carnac to tell me if I could recover in time, but there must be some guidelines.  

The guidelines are pretty much individual.

The Oly I did this past weekend...I rode 70 and ran 16 the weekend before, and didn't start my taper till the Thursday before the race.  I was pretty much recovered when I toed the line on Sunday...YMMV.

2012-05-24 1:50 PM
in reply to: #4227603

User image

Champion
10018
50005000
, Minnesota
Bronze member
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

Okay, thanks!    It sounds like if I feel recovered, I might have gained something, so it's worthwhile (within reason).   I do have a fairly good idea of my time for recovery - I didn't know for sure if feeling recovered would mean I'd done myself any good.  I swear, I am smart in other things but training is a bit of a mystery to me.

I am going to do two more longer rides (Friday and one weekend day) and make sure to get my runs in plus at least one OWS.    I feel like my best bet is to get my bike fitness as "in shape" as I can manage.    I'll still go full taper next week and fortunately the race is on Sunday.   My best half marathons have been on a two week taper, which is why I am nervous.  I just take a bit more time to feel better.

2012-05-24 1:58 PM
in reply to: #4227636

User image

Pro
5361
50001001001002525
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

you've got 10 days.  That's about the minimum for adaptation to take place.

So- it's taper time.   don't do anything stupid between now and then.

 good luck, have fun.

2012-05-24 2:22 PM
in reply to: #4227636

User image

Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
BikerGrrrl - 2012-05-24 8:50 AM

Okay, thanks!    It sounds like if I feel recovered, I might have gained something, so it's worthwhile (within reason).   I do have a fairly good idea of my time for recovery - I didn't know for sure if feeling recovered would mean I'd done myself any good.  I swear, I am smart in other things but training is a bit of a mystery to me.

I am going to do two more longer rides (Friday and one weekend day) and make sure to get my runs in plus at least one OWS.    I feel like my best bet is to get my bike fitness as "in shape" as I can manage.    I'll still go full taper next week and fortunately the race is on Sunday.   My best half marathons have been on a two week taper, which is why I am nervous.  I just take a bit more time to feel better.

Well, even if you don't see actual "adaptations" by Sunday, you should see some benefit later down the road...which isn't a bad thing.  It doesn't sound like you're trying to qualify for the Olympics or anything next Sunday, so I would say train hard, rest up, race, and have fun.  Don't sweat the details.



2012-05-24 2:36 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Pro
4353
200020001001001002525
Wallingford, PA
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
IMO, you'll be fine continuing to train at a level consistent with what you have been doing for another several days before you really need to begin tapering. As others have said, how much rest/taper you need before a race is a pretty individual thing, but your volume is not super high, and I would guess you won't need a very long taper for your race. I would avoid the temptation to try to "cram a bunch of miles in" leading up to the race, though. IOW, don't try to do any extra-long or extra-hard training sessions between now an your race, just continue doing what you've been doing, and back off for a bit of a taper a few days before your race. Good luck and have fun!
2012-05-24 3:01 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Extreme Veteran
5722
5000500100100
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

Raceday Apollo provides some graphs that show the benefit of a workout X days out. So it shows you get maximum benefit say 15 days out, less and less as you get closer and negative benefit 5 days out and less. In fact it's 4 for the swim and 5 for run and bike.

Of course it's different for everyone and if you use the S/W and test a lot it's supposed to adapt to you.

But out of the box, for the normal person, less than 4-5 days out a  workout has negative effect.

Skiba is a pretty smart guy and I would believe this to be true.

2012-05-24 3:48 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Elite
5316
5000100100100
Alturas, California
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

You have time for one more build cycle in the next 3 weeks then it is just maintain until race day.  Workouts done less than 2 weeks prior to the race won't build your performance for the race, but you will maintain your fitness during those two weeks. 

What you don't want to do is build more than is reasonable in that time (not more than 1 mile per week build on your long run, etc. ). 

2012-05-24 4:36 PM
in reply to: #4227228


1055
10002525
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

If your not confident in this race, why not just train through it and schedule another race down the road?  You may not be able to gain fitness before this race, but you can gain fitness for a race a month down the road.

 

2012-05-24 4:50 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Elite
3913
20001000500100100100100
far northern CA
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?
I'm doing an oly on the same day.  This weekend, I plan on doing my usual long ride on Saturday and long run on Sunday but at easier speeds.  It's more about getting out with my friends and having a good time.  Why not just train through the race and use it as a benchmark for the type of training you should focus on for the rest of the season?  Good luck!


2012-05-24 5:11 PM
in reply to: #4227894

User image

Master
2563
20005002525
University Park, MD
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

Ok, so this is pushing a bit beyond the OP's query (simple answer: brigby's advice is very sensible). But I'm genuinely curious about the basis for claims like these:

Baowolf - 2012-05-24 4:48 PM

Workouts done less than 2 weeks prior to the race won't build your performance for the race

marcag - 2012-05-24 4:01 PM

But out of the box, for the normal person, less than 4-5 days out a  workout has negative effect.

If adaptation happens during recovery, and if most recovery happens in the few days after a workout, why should there be a need for a longer lag between training and adaptations? Of course, a really heavy training load, such as peak IM training, can take a couple of weeks to recover from. And elite athletes who are pushing themselves to the limit might take a while to fully recover from their peak training. But those extreme cases are not what we're looking at here. 

Most of us have probably had the experience of trying out some new activity. And then trying it again a (very) few days later and finding that we have improved at that activity. Doesn't that show that workouts can have rather rapid effects?

2012-05-24 5:14 PM
in reply to: #4227228

User image

Master
2855
20005001001001002525
Kailua, Hawaii
Subject: RE: How much can I still gain in fitness?

BikerGrrrl - 2012-05-25 5:58 AM

wanting to cram in a bunch of mileage by the end of the Memorial Day weekend.

Is there any point to that?  Will a good couple of swims this weekend really impact my performance positively the weekend after?  Do you see any harm in working my little heart out this weekend in all three sports?

yes and no.  depends on how much you plan on doing relative to your training base till now. I'd say be reasonable with your mileage plans. At this point, you may improve a bit on speed, but I highly doubt it will help your endurance. Definitely wouldn't blow yourself out with a heavy workout. Shorter speed intervals would be a better idea.

As for my thoughts on tapering, I think it's usually overdone, still necessary, but perhaps not as drastic as many make it out to be. Certainly plan on getting good rest on those legs following your last weekend...

New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » How much can I still gain in fitness? Rss Feed