Clicking in my shoes just isn't clicking

Just keep practicing.

Although, if after a week or two there is no improvement, it is possible that the problem cleat is not properly adjusted. 

Has it ever been easy to clip in?

If not try to clip shoe into pedals by hand holding the shoe and see if you can get it in smoothly.

If you can get it in easily when not on the bike then it is a skill issue. Do you have a trainer? If so try clipping in and out on trainer. If you don't have a trainer put bike in hall hold walls and practice or have a friend help hold you up trying to clip in and out.

Much easier to use trainer as you don't have to worry about balance.

Yes, it's a skill issue.  On the trainer or on the street, I can't seem to find the sweet spot easily.  I have the pedal all the way to the bottom.  Is that what most do?

I usually have the pedal near the 3 o'clock position when I'm trying to clip in. If I were you I'd try experimenting with different spots to see if one clicks for you.

Also, if you're on the trainer, don't be afraid to take a look down at what your doingwhile clipping in. Then you'll be better able to visualize what you need when you're on the road.

A great idea (for speedplays) and if you do not have speed plays I would say tri them out you will never go back. I have ridden Look pedals since the 80's (yes I'm older thank you) and switch to speedplays and have never looked back...

(some pun intended)

I think I might be a little confused.  Are you clipping in after a "flying" type mount or from a stop at a stop sign or light?  If you are clipping in after a stop, you should have one foot already clipped in.  For example, I always unclip my left foot at a stop sign and put it on the ground.  My right foot stays clipped in.  I then rotate my right foot to about the 1 o'clock position and push down to start rolling.  When the left pedal comes to the top, I clip in my left foot.  Same thing at the start of a ride.  Throw your leg over the bike, clip in the right foot (in my case), rotate to 1:00, push down to start rolling, clip in left at top.

I'm coming off of my run and starting on the bike.  No "flying" start. It's the "throw the leg over the bike and clip the right foot in" that I have trouble with.  I just can't seem to find it quickly.

ejshowers - 2013-03-26 2:27 PM Maybe ask Dorothy for some help in shoe clicking??? 

I was gonna post something like that

I think this and practice will be all you need... maybe "slow down" and save some time by getting it clip in the 1st time...

I put mine at the bottom so I have something to push aginst...