Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please!
-
No new posts
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller | Reply |
|
2014-07-17 9:28 AM |
Veteran 2842 Austin, Texas | Subject: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! OK, I've been searching for this on BT but haven't found really anything (or my search skillz suck). We're moving to Texas, which I'm told is… um… warm. So, there will be many non-wettie swims in my future. As such, I'm wondering about swim speed suits (or whatever you call the non-wetsuit, fabric suits many wear in non-wetsuit-legal swims). Questions are mostly general (what does one need to know about them; particular considerations; are there times when they are indicated and others when not; etc.), but would love to hear anyone's experience with particular suits and such. Just trying to figure it out before I enter the oven in a couple weeks!! Matt |
|
2014-07-17 11:54 AM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Pro 6520 Bellingham, WA | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! I bought an Xterra Velocity-M speedsuit several years ago when new WTC rules outlawed my Blue Seventy speedsuit. I used the suits for the Hawaii 70.3 in 2009 and 2011. I did some testing in the pool with both suits and they definately were measurably faster. I do not recall the exact amounts but at least a few seconds per 100. I really didn't see a downside. The Xterra speedsuit lists for $350 but I think I paid about $150. |
2014-07-17 12:07 PM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Veteran 1677 Houston, Texas | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Thanks for asking the question, Matt....I had been wondering the same thing, but then promptly signed up for a wetsuit legal race, with no non-wetsuit races likely till next year. When I OWS in my tri top, it's like a freaking parachute! Are there any brands that are better than others? Some are legal for all races, and some for just some races, right? Definitely on my list of things to research and purchase (also living in TX). |
2014-07-17 12:10 PM in reply to: 0 |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 OK, I've been searching for this on BT but haven't found really anything (or my search skillz suck). We're moving to Texas, which I'm told is… um… warm. So, there will be many non-wettie swims in my future. As such, I'm wondering about swim speed suits (or whatever you call the non-wetsuit, fabric suits many wear in non-wetsuit-legal swims). Questions are mostly general (what does one need to know about them; particular considerations; are there times when they are indicated and others when not; etc.), but would love to hear anyone's experience with particular suits and such. Just trying to figure it out before I enter the oven in a couple weeks!! Matt You know me, I measure everything :-) Tyr torque - 3s/100 - zipper broke-crappy customer service IMO Huub 3s/100 - great customer service Multiple, multiple runs, very consistent results. PS : I will be experimenting with the DeSoto, starting tomorrow :-) It is ITU legal, which the Tyr and Huub are not Edited by marcag 2014-07-17 12:14 PM |
2014-07-17 12:12 PM in reply to: 0 |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! |
2014-07-17 12:51 PM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Elite 3088 Austin, TX | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Austin based and I've got the Tyr Torque. If I'm racing, I'm either in my wetsuit or my speed suit. I can't see any situation where they're not warranted. Since the wetsuit takes longer to get off but also saves more time, my break even point for both is about the same: 200m. Any swim longer than that and I save more time than I lose. |
|
2014-07-17 1:07 PM in reply to: marcag |
Master 9705 Raleigh, NC area | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 You know me, I measure everything :-) Tyr torque - 3s/100 - zipper broke-crappy customer service IMO Huub 3s/100 - great customer service Multiple, multiple runs, very consistent results. PS : I will be experimenting with the DeSoto, starting tomorrow :-) It is ITU legal, which the Tyr and Huub are not OK, I've been searching for this on BT but haven't found really anything (or my search skillz suck). We're moving to Texas, which I'm told is… um… warm. So, there will be many non-wettie swims in my future. As such, I'm wondering about swim speed suits (or whatever you call the non-wetsuit, fabric suits many wear in non-wetsuit-legal swims). Questions are mostly general (what does one need to know about them; particular considerations; are there times when they are indicated and others when not; etc.), but would love to hear anyone's experience with particular suits and such. Just trying to figure it out before I enter the oven in a couple weeks!! Matt Roka gets good reviews over on That Other forum. Any thoughts on them? |
2014-07-17 1:33 PM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! I've got the B70 PZ3TX. I haven't tested it in the pool, but when OWS training in a protected and well marked lagoon, I'm about 2-3 seconds per 100y faster. Make sure it fits well. You want it snug. I didn't sense any problems with over heating...but most of my swims were in 75-80 degree water. I like the zipper on the PZ3TX. It's one of those locking zippers so to remove it, you just flip the tab up, and it self unzipps as you pull the speedsuit off your shoulders. No cords...you just may need a friend to help you zip up. I got my used of the ST classifieds for about 150 I think. Looked to be in almost new condition (seller said used once). At full retail price, it's a bit harder to justify...but I got it before going to Kona last year. Even lottery winners have to look the part when you're in Kona right? At least look fast at the starting line...let them find out you're slow later. |
2014-07-17 1:56 PM in reply to: jmkizer |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by jmkizer Roka gets good reviews over on That Other forum. Any thoughts on them? Never tried it, but given the company, I suspect the performance will be good. |
2014-07-17 1:58 PM in reply to: dgunthert |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by dgunthert I can't see any situation where they're not warranted. WTC allows them, ITU doesn't. So for example Matt qualified for Worlds in Sweden. If it's not wetsuit, he can't wear a swimskin. He can wear something like the DeSoto whcih is a tri suit. |
2014-07-17 2:14 PM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Member 587 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Just an FYI - USAT is considering changing their swim skin rules for next season. I am not sure if they will adopt the WTC rule or something else but just be aware that change is likely for next season. |
|
2014-07-17 7:15 PM in reply to: 5stones |
Veteran 2297 Great White North | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! I suspect they would adopt the ITU rule vs WTC. ITU rule is one suit for the whole race, so suits like ZeroS, Kiwanis and Desoto will dominate. |
2014-07-17 7:16 PM in reply to: mcmanusclan5 |
Veteran 2297 Great White North | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! If you are racing Olympic or shorter get a ITU style Trisuit. |
2014-07-17 7:38 PM in reply to: simpsonbo |
Master 3888 Overland Park, KS | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Skip the Speed Suits, you just need to kick more, do some of those 2,500 yd kick sets I'm actually trying one out this Sunday (Bargain from Hannulink) for the first time, assuming water temp is above 78. |
2014-07-17 7:45 PM in reply to: 0 |
Pro 15655 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by simpsonbo If you are racing Olympic or shorter get a ITU style Trisuit. This^^ Kiwami suits have survived the test of time for us. Edited by Left Brain 2014-07-17 7:46 PM |
2014-07-17 8:05 PM in reply to: reecealan |
Veteran 627 Prairie Village, Kansas | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by reecealan Skip the Speed Suits, you just need to kick more, do some of those 2,500 yd kick sets I'm actually trying one out this Sunday (Bargain from Hannulink) for the first time, assuming water temp is above 78. ME TOO! I got a Tyr Torque Lite on the cheap... But I think I'll be able to wear a wetsuit. |
|
2014-07-17 8:12 PM in reply to: Left Brain |
Veteran 1677 Houston, Texas | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by Left Brain Originally posted by simpsonbo If you are racing Olympic or shorter get a ITU style Trisuit. This^^ Kiwami suits have survived the test of time for us. How do they compare to a speed suit (say one that's WTC legal)? I almost pulled the trigger on one a couple months ago, but no longer have any non-wetsuit races on the schedule. |
2014-07-18 6:35 AM in reply to: ligersandtions |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by ligersandtions Originally posted by Left Brain Originally posted by simpsonbo If you are racing Olympic or shorter get a ITU style Trisuit. This^^ Kiwami suits have survived the test of time for us. How do they compare to a speed suit (say one that's WTC legal)? I almost pulled the trigger on one a couple months ago, but no longer have any non-wetsuit races on the schedule. They will probably be comparable for a person like you. The skin suit does 3 things a) it it supposed to repel water, so be a little slippery through the water b) it compresses quite a bit so less volume to move through the water c) it eliminates drag from pockets in your tri suit PS : when I said 3 seconds faster, I meant compared to a speedo The ITU type suit a) Not sure if the material is hydrophobic (I think it is) b) maybe compresses a little less. You do wear it for the bike and run therefore comfort is more of a factor c) depends on if it has pockets or not. Not sure. d) The chamois actually floats a little, so it's supposedly like a small pull bouy. Nothing that can't be corrected by 3000m kick sets however. this is my understanding of it. I am picking up a Desoto in an hour so I'll let you know :-) One advantage of the DeSoto is the no BS return policy. Fit is everything and comfort on the long stuff you do is critical. While the "technology" is important, I think the customer service angle is equally important. I will never buy a Tyr product again. Huub and Desoto have been amazing. |
2014-07-18 8:03 AM in reply to: marcag |
Master 10208 Northern IL | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by ligersandtions They will probably be comparable for a person like you. The skin suit does 3 things a) it it supposed to repel water, so be a little slippery through the water b) it compresses quite a bit so less volume to move through the water c) it eliminates drag from pockets in your tri suit PS : when I said 3 seconds faster, I meant compared to a speedo The ITU type suit a) Not sure if the material is hydrophobic (I think it is) b) maybe compresses a little less. You do wear it for the bike and run therefore comfort is more of a factor c) depends on if it has pockets or not. Not sure. d) The chamois actually floats a little, so it's supposedly like a small pull bouy. Nothing that can't be corrected by 3000m kick sets however. this is my understanding of it. I am picking up a Desoto in an hour so I'll let you know :-) One advantage of the DeSoto is the no BS return policy. Fit is everything and comfort on the long stuff you do is critical. While the "technology" is important, I think the customer service angle is equally important. I will never buy a Tyr product again. Huub and Desoto have been amazing. Originally posted by Left Brain Originally posted by simpsonbo If you are racing Olympic or shorter get a ITU style Trisuit. This^^ Kiwami suits have survived the test of time for us. How do they compare to a speed suit (say one that's WTC legal)? I almost pulled the trigger on one a couple months ago, but no longer have any non-wetsuit races on the schedule. I used the DeSoto LIftfoil as a trisuit for a season. It's pretty well built, seems like it would hold up for a long time. The cut was a little short in height to get the needed snugness though, pulled on my shoulders later in the races. The pad was a bit wide for me too. I don't know if it's as good as others for hotter races as it seemed heavier/thicker. Nice to have for the cooler ones though. Switched to a Kiwami Amphibian last year and loved it. Incredibly light feeling and holds snug. Cut for an athlete too. No amount of splashing gets the thing wet. I have to get in the water. It is a back zip, but I've actually felt less restricted in this than the several front zip suits. No need to zip up for the finish line photo! I don't know if it's exactly the same as a swimskin, but it'll be more competitive towards that. I haven't looked into the new Spider yet, but the Konami is supposed to be the long course version, pockets and front zip. Both DeSoto and Kiwami were very helpful. |
2014-07-18 8:34 AM in reply to: brigby1 |
Veteran 2842 Austin, Texas | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Super helpful all - many thanks! Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. I just read a short piece in Triathlete last night about skinz and time savings. They claimed a consistent 2s/100 advantage for the skinz (compared the 3s you experience Marc) and 6s/100 for wetties (although I see more like 10s/100 - I know, prolly from bad form). If the ITU suit is close to a swimskin and comfortable, it would be tougher to go with a swimskin from a time savings standpoint, I'd think (?). Thoughts on one vs. the other? Brings another question to mind (which I've asked before to some good natured derision). For those of us who are more hirsuite (hairsuit?) than others, is the slipperiness of these suits undone somewhat by a set of hairy shoulders and arms (and legs) hanging out in the slipstream? Having just swum with a sunshirt and shorts (rather than jammers) last week and noticing a big drag difference, I'm wondering if I'll see some speed bump just from wearing something over my "sweater." The replies from pool fishies to this question in the past have all been that shaving psychs you up for race day but otherwise has no effect. If that's so, how does an ITU suit make you faster than jammers (assuming minimal compression)? (and if this question truly is silly, just say so and I'll try to stop asking!) Off to do 3k of kick. Matt |
2014-07-18 5:53 PM in reply to: 0 |
Extreme Veteran 5722 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. I won't be providing numbers. People won't believe me :-) Either this suit is very fast or that 200m of kicking I did yesterday is finally yielding results. Seriously...for me, the DeSoto is hands down better Would I wear it for a HIM or longer ? I don't know. My regular shorts/top are more comfortable. But for an Oly, hands down. Skimskin allows you to be more selective on your bike/run attire which is not negligeable on 70.3 and greater. I am very surprised of the results. I need to do more testing. They were that good. Edited by marcag 2014-07-18 6:06 PM |
|
2014-07-18 8:02 PM in reply to: marcag |
Pro 6582 Melbourne FL | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 I won't be providing numbers. People won't believe me :-) Either this suit is very fast or that 200m of kicking I did yesterday is finally yielding results. Seriously...for me, the DeSoto is hands down better Would I wear it for a HIM or longer ? I don't know. My regular shorts/top are more comfortable. But for an Oly, hands down. Skimskin allows you to be more selective on your bike/run attire which is not negligeable on 70.3 and greater. I am very surprised of the results. I need to do more testing. They were that good. Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. Just to be sure, you're talking about the Liftfoil right? If so I'd be interested on your thoughts of the 7mm pad. Maybe the pad lifted you more than you think! I love the fit and feel of Desoto tri suits but mine are the older models with the thin Fleece pad and wonder if the 7mm pad would be too much. I need a new suit and have been looking at the Forza and the Riviera suits, god knows I could use all the help I can get for the swim and my next tri (2k swim) most likely won't be wetsuit legal. |
2014-07-18 8:06 PM in reply to: marcag |
Pro 15655 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 I won't be providing numbers. People won't believe me :-) Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. If it provides that much of an advantage it should be illegal to use. |
2014-07-18 8:20 PM in reply to: 0 |
Pro 6582 Melbourne FL | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by Left Brain Like shaving your legs for the bike!?!Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 I won't be providing numbers. People won't believe me :-) Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. If it provides that much of an advantage it should be illegal to use. Edited by Donto 2014-07-18 8:20 PM |
2014-07-18 8:21 PM in reply to: Donto |
Pro 15655 | Subject: RE: Hey BT, geek me up on swim speed suits, please! Originally posted by Donto Originally posted by Left Brain Like shaving your legs for the bike!?!Originally posted by marcag Originally posted by mcmanusclan5 I won't be providing numbers. People won't believe me :-) Marc, I'll be curious to hear what the time differences are between the skinz and the DeSoto. If it provides that much of an advantage it should be illegal to use. Of course not. |
|