General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Is it just me? Rss Feed  
Moderators: k9car363, alicefoeller Reply
 
 
of 2
 
 
2014-09-15 12:08 PM

User image

Expert
1051
10002525
Bradenton, Florida
Subject: Is it just me?
Anyone else enjoy the full contact swim at the beginning of the race?

There are plenty of threads about fear and swimming, kayakers and swimming, pool vs. OWS, to flip turn or not, but there has to be a few others that actually look forward to the washing machine, full contact, survival of the fittest, sprint to the first buoy. Or is it just me?

Edited by cwpeters 2014-09-15 12:14 PM


2014-09-15 12:28 PM
in reply to: cwpeters

User image


239
10010025
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

My first couple tri's were TT starts. I was actually disappointed as I wanted to try the mass start. I'm not sure if I actually look forward to it now that I've done a few, but I definitely don't mind it.

2014-09-15 12:28 PM
in reply to: cwpeters

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I don't liket much and try to avoid it as I don't swim well....BUT.....the kids I'm around who swim at the Jr. level just love it.  At AG nationals this year my kid said that when his AG lined up he was looking around and quite a few of them knew each other from the Jr. Elite series, etc.  He said there was quite a bit of jockeying for position and that every time he caught one of those kid's eyes they shared a big smile with each other, knowing what was coming. Some of the races he does are wars on the swim, and those kids are truly battle tested. ......and I've watched him and his sister practice for hours in our small backyard pool learning to roll over other swimmers, etc. You are not alone.

2014-09-15 12:30 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

nationals was a rough swim.

 

2014-09-15 12:34 PM
in reply to: dmiller5

User image

Pro
5761
50005001001002525
Bartlett, TN
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I would not say I love it, but I also do not fear it. Bumping in the water doesn't bother me, and I am lucky enough to have never been kicked hard or hit across the face yet. As long as it is done in competition and not as a deliberate act, then I am good.

2014-09-15 12:46 PM
in reply to: cwpeters


701
500100100
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
I try to avoid it.
This weekend was my first mass start, and it was less violent than the age group, 6 at a time, every 10 seconds or whatever it was in Des Moines for the Hyvee. It was a smaller race, and I intentionally hung back and avoided the rush.

Here's where my question comes in. Etiquette-wise.

For sure, if someone tags me from behind, I do my best to get out of the way ASAP and move towards the 'outside'.
I tend to kind of do the same when I do the tagging. I generally use that as a good time to take a good sighting look, maybe take a few deep breaths (as I don't seem to develop a good breathing rhythm until the last .25 of any longer swim).

Should I just try to alter course a tad and keep crashing if I catch someone from behind? It's sort of a guess, though at the old "Crazy Ivan" as to which way they might (or might not) try to alter course.

In these last two races, I did find that it's a bit taxing to get momentum back after more or less coming to a near dead stop. I gotta find a way to stop doing that. It could be one of the reasons that it's taking me so long to find some of the consistency as the pack starts to thin out towards the end. Especially when I end up just running up on them again.

I've definitely been spoiled in the open water races I've done up through now.


2014-09-15 12:54 PM
in reply to: jhaack39

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

Originally posted by jhaack39 I try to avoid it. This weekend was my first mass start, and it was less violent than the age group, 6 at a time, every 10 seconds or whatever it was in Des Moines for the Hyvee. It was a smaller race, and I intentionally hung back and avoided the rush. Here's where my question comes in. Etiquette-wise. For sure, if someone tags me from behind, I do my best to get out of the way ASAP and move towards the 'outside'. I tend to kind of do the same when I do the tagging. I generally use that as a good time to take a good sighting look, maybe take a few deep breaths (as I don't seem to develop a good breathing rhythm until the last .25 of any longer swim). Should I just try to alter course a tad and keep crashing if I catch someone from behind? It's sort of a guess, though at the old "Crazy Ivan" as to which way they might (or might not) try to alter course. In these last two races, I did find that it's a bit taxing to get momentum back after more or less coming to a near dead stop. I gotta find a way to stop doing that. It could be one of the reasons that it's taking me so long to find some of the consistency as the pack starts to thin out towards the end. Especially when I end up just running up on them again. I've definitely been spoiled in the open water races I've done up through now.

Swim!  It's not a pool swimming laps....in fact, I've never heard of someone thinking they can tap the foot in front of them, in an open water swim race, and that person will give way.  If someone wants to pass you they can swim faster, or over you, or whatever....it's a race.  You are under no obligtation, or etiquette, to stop swimming so they can pass.

2014-09-15 1:06 PM
in reply to: jhaack39

User image

Expert
3126
2000100010025
Boise, ID
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

Originally posted by jhaack39 I try to avoid it. This weekend was my first mass start, and it was less violent than the age group, 6 at a time, every 10 seconds or whatever it was in Des Moines for the Hyvee. It was a smaller race, and I intentionally hung back and avoided the rush. Here's where my question comes in. Etiquette-wise. For sure, if someone tags me from behind, I do my best to get out of the way ASAP and move towards the 'outside'. I tend to kind of do the same when I do the tagging. I generally use that as a good time to take a good sighting look, maybe take a few deep breaths (as I don't seem to develop a good breathing rhythm until the last .25 of any longer swim). Should I just try to alter course a tad and keep crashing if I catch someone from behind? It's sort of a guess, though at the old "Crazy Ivan" as to which way they might (or might not) try to alter course. In these last two races, I did find that it's a bit taxing to get momentum back after more or less coming to a near dead stop. I gotta find a way to stop doing that. It could be one of the reasons that it's taking me so long to find some of the consistency as the pack starts to thin out towards the end. Especially when I end up just running up on them again. I've definitely been spoiled in the open water races I've done up through now.

Etiquette varies depending on your position in the race.

If you are a FOP swimmer there aren't much for rules. As LB said, it is a race, swim as fast as you can as hard as you can and expect to get knocked around and do some knocking back.

For those of us in the MOP or BOP on the swim it is more of getting it done in a decent time or just surviving. There are still no "rules" but the following works well for me. If I touch feet in front of my that is my que to alter course and go around them. I will go to the side a bit and pass them. Once I am front of them I will go easy on the kicking for a bit until there is some space.

If I feel someone brush my feet with their hands I will reduce my kick or stop kicking to give them a chance to go to the side before they get kicked in the face. I do not alter course, if they want to go around me it is up to them to get it done. I do stop the kicking or slow it down just as a courtesy as I know I don't like getting kicked in the face, but I don't slow down or change course to "get out of the way". Worked well for me and the people around me in my IM swim and many seemed to do the same.

The one thing that does pi$$ me off in OWS is when some d-bag decides to breast stroke. Some "large" individual in my IM swim thought it would be cool to breast stroke/frog kick as he couldn't hack it. Caught my square in the chest as I come up beside him, never wanted to drown someone so much in my life. As I went by he kicked 3-4 other people as well. Total d1ck move. 

2014-09-15 1:10 PM
in reply to: cwpeters


34
25
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
To the OP, I'm with you, I love it!!! I grew up swimming, and lifeguarded at the beach, so my comfort level is a little different. I just did a sprint this weekend and was so amped up at the start. Such a rush sprinting into the water, diving through the surf and being the first around the buoy!!!
2014-09-15 1:22 PM
in reply to: CzechYourHead

User image

New user
1351
10001001001002525
Austin, Texas
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I kinda like it too, but then again I haven't come out of the water with a broken jaw like some people have.

2014-09-15 1:31 PM
in reply to: Aarondb4

User image

Member
2689
2000500100252525
Denver, CO
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

Originally posted by Aarondb4

Etiquette varies depending on your position in the race.

If you are a FOP swimmer there aren't much for rules. As LB said, it is a race, swim as fast as you can as hard as you can and expect to get knocked around and do some knocking back.

For those of us in the MOP or BOP on the swim it is more of getting it done in a decent time or just surviving. There are still no "rules" but the following works well for me. If I touch feet in front of my that is my que to alter course and go around them. I will go to the side a bit and pass them. Once I am front of them I will go easy on the kicking for a bit until there is some space.

If I feel someone brush my feet with their hands I will reduce my kick or stop kicking to give them a chance to go to the side before they get kicked in the face. I do not alter course, if they want to go around me it is up to them to get it done. I do stop the kicking or slow it down just as a courtesy as I know I don't like getting kicked in the face, but I don't slow down or change course to "get out of the way". Worked well for me and the people around me in my IM swim and many seemed to do the same.

The one thing that does pi$$ me off in OWS is when some d-bag decides to breast stroke. Some "large" individual in my IM swim thought it would be cool to breast stroke/frog kick as he couldn't hack it. Caught my square in the chest as I come up beside him, never wanted to drown someone so much in my life. As I went by he kicked 3-4 other people as well. Total d1ck move. 

Sometimes breast stroke the only stroke people know how to do.  I give them credit for even tackling a tri when they can't swim freestyle.  Now, if they were FOP, that might be one thing, but as you said, for MOP/BOP folks, it's mostly just a matter of finishing.  If they have to breast stroke to do it, then so be it.  It's not like they're doing it just to intentionally kick people. 



2014-09-15 1:33 PM
in reply to: laffinrock

User image

Extreme Veteran
3025
2000100025
Maryland
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

Originally posted by laffinrock

Originally posted by Aarondb4

Etiquette varies depending on your position in the race.

If you are a FOP swimmer there aren't much for rules. As LB said, it is a race, swim as fast as you can as hard as you can and expect to get knocked around and do some knocking back.

For those of us in the MOP or BOP on the swim it is more of getting it done in a decent time or just surviving. There are still no "rules" but the following works well for me. If I touch feet in front of my that is my que to alter course and go around them. I will go to the side a bit and pass them. Once I am front of them I will go easy on the kicking for a bit until there is some space.

If I feel someone brush my feet with their hands I will reduce my kick or stop kicking to give them a chance to go to the side before they get kicked in the face. I do not alter course, if they want to go around me it is up to them to get it done. I do stop the kicking or slow it down just as a courtesy as I know I don't like getting kicked in the face, but I don't slow down or change course to "get out of the way". Worked well for me and the people around me in my IM swim and many seemed to do the same.

The one thing that does pi$$ me off in OWS is when some d-bag decides to breast stroke. Some "large" individual in my IM swim thought it would be cool to breast stroke/frog kick as he couldn't hack it. Caught my square in the chest as I come up beside him, never wanted to drown someone so much in my life. As I went by he kicked 3-4 other people as well. Total d1ck move. 

Sometimes breast stroke the only stroke people know how to do.  I give them credit for even tackling a tri when they can't swim freestyle.  Now, if they were FOP, that might be one thing, but as you said, for MOP/BOP folks, it's mostly just a matter of finishing.  If they have to breast stroke to do it, then so be it.  It's not like they're doing it just to intentionally kick people. 

Or maybe they could properly prepare for the sport they are attempting rather than putting the safety of others at risk?

2014-09-15 1:45 PM
in reply to: cwpeters

User image

Champion
7036
5000200025
Sarasota, FL
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I really don't enjoy it. 

Mark

 

2014-09-15 1:47 PM
in reply to: dmiller5

User image


754
5001001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
I don't like the contact because I swim my best when I can get into a rhythm, and bumping interferes with that. It hasn't occurred to me that I should get out of the way if someone bumps me from behind. When I run into someone's feet, I assume that it is my responsibility to turn.
2014-09-15 1:47 PM
in reply to: cwpeters


98
252525
, Idaho
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
I'm sure once I get punched in the face and a broke nose or kicked in the ribs so something cracks, I'll change my opinion, but for now I agree with the OP.

It's like in Football, where you can't wait to get tackled the first time. All the jitters are out, it's real, you've been punched once...you're alive...and ready to go again.

Contact at the beginning of the swim just gets the competitive juices going. Part of the fun of triathlon is you're constantly rubbing/bumping/almost crashing into each other during the sbr portions and also transition.

It's part of the race, so I embrace it.
2014-09-15 1:58 PM
in reply to: cwpeters


1055
10002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
I'm by no means a fish, but I have more trouble with contact going through slower swimmers in the earlier waves than in my own wave. Unless you're in a 100+ person wave, not sure why you would say it's full contact. Sure there is contact, but it's not as bad as people make it out to be so longer as you seed yourself properly at the start.

That said, no I don't enjoy it, but it is a part of the race and I probably dish it out just as much as I receive it.


2014-09-15 2:11 PM
in reply to: cwpeters

User image

Extreme Veteran
933
50010010010010025
Connecticut
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
If I'm in a shorter race where I'm not in the first wave out, I'll stay wide and vigilant as opposed to gunning it, otherwise I invariably get kicked by a breast stroker in the wave ahead as I pass. That hurts bad. An elbow to the head, not so much, as long as it's not malicious, which I've never seen. You might think it's malicious in the moment, but it's not. If you're FOP and you're getting hit, you're not doing a good enough job of jockeying for position. You should be able position yourself in such a way where you're swimming your stroke without getting bonked, even if you or someone in your vicinity goes off course.

Another school of thought though, which I've been playing with recently on shorter course - If you can quickly get to the front of the middle and hold it without sprinting, but a stroke or two behind the back of the front. There is NO jockeying there - it's clear water ahead for a body length and it sorts out from side to side just fine. I prefer settling in, what can I say. Then you uncork a sprint in the middle third and catch up as the front pack is getting ready for their kick. I get to pick a pair of feet and draft a good choice on the kick in. Bingo, you get a FOP finish without a scrum. I've only tried it twice, but it worked. A variation for longer distances, still start out slower and turn it on a bit in the middle, you still catch the front as they flag down a bit. The absolute front fish are long gone by then, and mentally some FOPers check out a bit once they realize that, perfect time to slide in among them.
2014-09-15 2:20 PM
in reply to: fisherman76

User image

Pro
15655
5000500050005001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

Originally posted by fisherman76 If I'm in a shorter race where I'm not in the first wave out, I'll stay wide and vigilant as opposed to gunning it, otherwise I invariably get kicked by a breast stroker in the wave ahead as I pass. That hurts bad. An elbow to the head, not so much, as long as it's not malicious, which I've never seen. You might think it's malicious in the moment, but it's not. If you're FOP and you're getting hit, you're not doing a good enough job of jockeying for position. You should be able position yourself in such a way where you're swimming your stroke without getting bonked, even if you or someone in your vicinity goes off course. Another school of thought though, which I've been playing with recently on shorter course - If you can quickly get to the front of the middle and hold it without sprinting, but a stroke or two behind the back of the front. There is NO jockeying there - it's clear water ahead for a body length and it sorts out from side to side just fine. I prefer settling in, what can I say. Then you uncork a sprint in the middle third and catch up as the front pack is getting ready for their kick. I get to pick a pair of feet and draft a good choice on the kick in. Bingo, you get a FOP finish without a scrum. I've only tried it twice, but it worked. A variation for longer distances, still start out slower and turn it on a bit in the middle, you still catch the front as they flag down a bit. The absolute front fish are long gone by then, and mentally some FOPers check out a bit once they realize that, perfect time to slide in among them.

Sometimes the faster you get the worse it is.  At some of the races we go to 50% of the racers can swim a 5:00 500......it's ALWAYS brutal at the first buoy. A few might make it through clean, but the rest are in for a fight.   Even at AG nationals 2 years ago they necked the swim down in both directions under a bridge.  It gave you maybe 15 yards to get through in both directtions, with 3 or 4 swim waves overlapping......it was a MESS for the folks who don't like to deal with contact.  The bottom line, even as much as I don't enjoy the contact but understand it's part of the deal, is that you should be well prepared for contact in any open water triathlon swim.  if you aren't, do pool swim races until you are.  That may include, as dmiller said, sitting out until you can freestlye the length of your race.

2014-09-15 2:22 PM
in reply to: jhaack39

User image

New user
246
10010025
madison, Wisconsin
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
Originally posted by jhaack39

I try to avoid it.
This weekend was my first mass start, and it was less violent than the age group, 6 at a time, every 10 seconds or whatever it was in Des Moines for the Hyvee. It was a smaller race, and I intentionally hung back and avoided the rush.

Here's where my question comes in. Etiquette-wise.

For sure, if someone tags me from behind, I do my best to get out of the way ASAP and move towards the 'outside'.
I tend to kind of do the same when I do the tagging. I generally use that as a good time to take a good sighting look, maybe take a few deep breaths (as I don't seem to develop a good breathing rhythm until the last .25 of any longer swim).

Should I just try to alter course a tad and keep crashing if I catch someone from behind? It's sort of a guess, though at the old "Crazy Ivan" as to which way they might (or might not) try to alter course.

In these last two races, I did find that it's a bit taxing to get momentum back after more or less coming to a near dead stop. I gotta find a way to stop doing that. It could be one of the reasons that it's taking me so long to find some of the consistency as the pack starts to thin out towards the end. Especially when I end up just running up on them again.

I've definitely been spoiled in the open water races I've done up through now.

I was in this same race, likely very close to each other. That one was a bad one as the water was the darkest I've ever been in, and I've swum in some dirty water. All of the rain they had over the previous week made the water in DM very muddy so you couldn't see your elbow when it was extended in front of you. That, in turn, translated to a LOT of contact. Simply because you couldn't see anyone until you were right on top of them. I was side-by-side with a fellow and we were just very evenly matched speed-wise. Problem being that we just kept hitting each other. I had, and I'm sure he had, bruises on my upper arms from his elbows. When we got out of the water we both offered a quick "sorry for the contact", shook hands and went about our way.
I agree with the others that say it's not your job to yield or get out of anyone's way. If they are overtaking you, they need to find a way to do it. Unfortunately, sometimes that means they are going right over the top of you. So if you are yielding for your own piece of mind, that's one thing, but you shouldn't need to move for anyone else.
2014-09-15 2:39 PM
in reply to: 0

User image

Pro
6520
50001000500
Bellingham, WA
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I don't mind it at all anymore.  Mainly because I have the confidence in the water to handle the situation.  I think I've also developed an extra gear so I can accelerate to take advantage of an opportunity or avoid trouble and then fall back into my race pace.

I to strongly dislike the threat of being kicked by a breaststroker.  When visibility is limited it can be hard to see to avoid and getting kicked in the face is a serious hazard.

If I feel a tap on my foot, I don't intepret it as a signal to let someone through.  More times than not it's someone drafting off me and that's fine unless it's every other stroke they are hitting me and than I'll try to lose them.



Edited by popsracer 2014-09-15 2:41 PM
2014-09-15 4:01 PM
in reply to: Left Brain

User image

Extreme Veteran
933
50010010010010025
Connecticut
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
Originally posted by Left Brain
Sometimes the faster you get the worse it is.  At some of the races we go to 50% of the racers can swim a 5:00 500......it's ALWAYS brutal at the first buoy. A few might make it through clean, but the rest are in for a fight.   Even at AG nationals 2 years ago they necked the swim down in both directions under a bridge.  It gave you maybe 15 yards to get through in both directtions, with 3 or 4 swim waves overlapping......it was a MESS for the folks who don't like to deal with contact.  The bottom line, even as much as I don't enjoy the contact but understand it's part of the deal, is that you should be well prepared for contact in any open water triathlon swim.  if you aren't, do pool swim races until you are.  That may include, as dmiller said, sitting out until you can freestlye the length of your race.




Agreed, and the shorter the distance, the worse still.

It's starting to become less and less fun on shorter distances, the whole race is getting decided in the first 10 minutes. I like more tactic


2014-09-15 6:05 PM
in reply to: cwpeters

User image

Pro
5361
50001001001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?

I always seize the opportunity to re-post this classic swim start video:

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3S0wu4Zbfk

 

 

2014-09-15 7:41 PM
in reply to: Aarondb4

User image

New user
80
252525
Howell, Michigan
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
...The one thing that does pi$$ me off in OWS is when some d-bag decides to breast stroke. Some "large" individual in my IM swim thought it would be cool to breast stroke/frog kick as he couldn't hack it. Caught my square in the chest as I come up beside him, never wanted to drown someone so much in my life. As I went by he kicked 3-4 other people as well. Total d1ck move...

I was in a similar situation about a month ago and got kicked in the jaw by a breast stroker. Broke a tooth.
2014-09-15 7:41 PM
in reply to: Aarondb4

User image

New user
80
252525
Howell, Michigan
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
...The one thing that does pi$$ me off in OWS is when some d-bag decides to breast stroke. Some "large" individual in my IM swim thought it would be cool to breast stroke/frog kick as he couldn't hack it. Caught my square in the chest as I come up beside him, never wanted to drown someone so much in my life. As I went by he kicked 3-4 other people as well. Total d1ck move...

I was in a similar situation about a month ago and got kicked in the jaw by a breast stroker. Broke a tooth.
2014-09-15 8:47 PM
in reply to: 0


471
1001001001002525
Subject: RE: Is it just me?
I play rugby so the physicality of it doesn't bother me and I'd be spewing if they did anything to stop the mass start, but I prefer to start my swim in a bit of space, get into a rhythm, then move back into the pack to draft. What does irritate me is that a lot of people go out too fast and are forced to slow down, forcing me to go out harder than I want to to make sure I don't get caught up behind them when they slow.

Edited by zedzded 2014-09-15 9:09 PM
New Thread
General Discussion Triathlon Talk » Is it just me? Rss Feed  
 
 
of 2
 
 
RELATED POSTS

I am a beginner and I am scared, but hopeful

Started by trisome
Views: 3080 Posts: 15

2013-08-07 7:47 AM Sidney Porter

Birth day Celebration? I hope I am that lucky when I am 90

Started by MrSolis
Views: 1475 Posts: 4

2009-01-03 4:25 PM MrSolis

trying to determine where I am, and where I am headed...

Started by lordkovacs
Views: 1512 Posts: 3

2008-08-08 9:12 AM lordkovacs

Am I stupid? Yes, I am.

Started by triguyfitz
Views: 1569 Posts: 5

2007-08-21 12:47 AM mm5093

First ever event - half iron man - I am am now a triathlete.

Started by sally888
Views: 1775 Posts: 14

2004-10-12 5:12 AM La Rakusillian
RELATED ARTICLES
date : May 5, 2008
author : TriPainter
comments : 1
I went into the pool area (as this was a pool swim) and got body marked. That's when it hit me that I was there to race - this was not a clinic.
 
date : September 24, 2007
author : mrakes1
comments : 0
Discussions on salt tablets, AM workout nutrition, coffee, post workout nutrition, whey powder, recovery nutrition, losing weight, Recoverite usage, the necessity of sugars and snack ideas.